League Winning Trade or Overpaid? Fuller & Montgomery for Godwin

[nutpunter 1]

Traded away Will Fuller + David Montgomery and got Chris Godwin back.

Context: 12 team, 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1flx, half ppr, 4 keepers, league.  Current record 3-0.

QBs:

• D. Watson
• C. Newton

WRs:

• Robert Woods
• Will Fuller
• Allen Lazard
• Preston Williams

RBs:

• C. McCaffrey
• J. Connors
• D. Montgomery
• M. Gaskin
• J. Kelley
• D. Freeman
• P. Lindsay

TE:

• Zach Ertz

Do you think this was a good trade?  Will it win the league (assuming it plays to the end)?  Or was this trade lopsided?

 

 

 

[AxeElf 787]

Wrong forum.

You start 3 WRs and you only have 4 WRs on your roster, including one who has been battling concussions (trading Fuller for Godwin)?

[weepaws 2,460]

When is Godwin due back on the playing field?

[nutpunter 1]

Expected out at least a week.  So far they think it'll be two since the second week is a Thurs night game.

[weepaws 2,460]

2 hours ago, nutpunter said:

Expected out at least a week.  So far they think it'll be two since the second week is a Thurs night game.

Thank you, I appreciate that info. 

[JagFan 97]

Not knowing the other roster it’s hard to say if it’s enough to help that team win the league, but they definitely came out on the better end of the trade IMO.

[Jarvis Basnight 119]

don't like the trade for you

 

[nobody 2,041]

Definitely collusion.  Veto.

[SaintsInDome2006 128]

17 hours ago, nutpunter said:

Traded away Will Fuller + David Montgomery and got Chris Godwin back.

Context: 12 team, 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1flx, half ppr, 4 keepers, league.  Current record 3-0.

QBs:

• D. Watson
• C. Newton

WRs:

• Robert Woods
• Will Fuller
• Allen Lazard
• Preston Williams

RBs:

• C. McCaffrey
• J. Connors
• D. Montgomery
• M. Gaskin
• J. Kelley
• D. Freeman
• P. Lindsay

TE:

• Zach Ertz

Do you think this was a good trade?  Will it win the league (assuming it plays to the end)?  Or was this trade lopsided?

I think it’s a good trade for you. Fuller is so unpredictable he’s almost unstartable, if it’s not the injuries it’s BOB & Watson going into a shell.

Montgomery is at a high value with Cohen going out and Foles coming in, but he has a tough matchup this week and if he does poorly then the value is back down again.

Predraft Godwin was often ranked around WR5. It’s potentially a good move IMO.

[pipeman 16]

I have Godwin as my #1, and I'm looking to trade him. Second right hamstring injury in 3 games dating back to last year. Speed guys and tweeked hammies don't mix well. Throw in the fact that his melon got rung in game 1. My all M.A.S.H. squad of Godwin, Fuller, Hilton, and DJ Moore has me constantly combing other rosters for trade partners.

[weepaws 2,460]

I think both Evans and Godwin would have a tough time finishing at their adp rankings with Brady at Qb.  

[SaintsInDome2006 128]

It’s still an Arians offense. I watched TB week 1, Godwin was the primary target.