Rodgers vs. Romo

[Foghorn Leghorn 0]

romo led a 13-3 team. the titans went 13-3 when VY was on the bench. romo > VY.

 

Based on your logic, Romo = Kerry Collins. Or will this just be another argument that all 12 of you use only when it backs your assertion?

[Blue_Star_Wrecking_Crew 0]

Based on your logic, Romo = Kerry Collins. Or will this just be another argument that all 12 of you use only when it backs your assertion?

look dude. rodgers is a very good qb. I am just saying romo has done more in his career. romo gets no respect here when he has put up big stats, never had a losing season and been to the playoffs. you want respect for rodgers give respect for romo.

 

Like I said before. this will be settled in january. romo vs rodgers. god, i want dallas to play the packers. finally send erin rodgers packing.

[PATSSOX 22]

look dude. rodgers is a very good qb. I am just saying romo has done more in his career. romo gets no respect here when he has put up big stats, never had a losing season and been to the playoffs. you want respect for rodgers give respect for romo.

 

Like I said before. this will be settled in january. romo vs rodgers. god, i want dallas to play the packers. finally send erin rodgers packing.

 

He has done more in his career because he has been the starting QB longer hasnt he Rodgers has not had the chance to fail yet and all Romo has done in playoffs is fail. So this year will be the deciding factor but id take them both well not unless Brady breaks another knee and shoulder or something....

[49ers_suck 0]

oh sweet jesus...here we go again. this is an amusing phenomenon that always seems to be brought up by eagles or giants fans. in a non-romo thread, if a cowboy fan brings up the number of pro bowlers, you guys scream "the pro bowl is a popularity contest, not an indication of the quality of the players" and "all those talentless guys are overrated".

 

but if the thread is about romo, the same people say "look at the incredible talent that they had on that team, and romo screwed it all up".

 

you guys said williams sucked, davis sucked, newman was overrated, flozell was overrated, and hamlin was overrated. hell--the kicker and the punter were pro bowlers, too.

 

and now, 2 years later, you guys still say that the same players suck--the only guys that aren't still there are ellis, williams, and TO (and lately folk). so 9 of the 13 are still cowboys.

 

that year, dallas had 2 1st team all-pros (a better indicator of performance): witten and ware. so evidently, they weren't quite the powerhouse that you're suggesting.

good post. i have made this point as well. this is more detailed.

 

how its spun depends on the agenda

[Blue_Star_Wrecking_Crew 0]

He has done more in his career because he has been the starting QB longer hasnt he Rodgers has not had the chance to fail yet and all Romo has done in playoffs is fail. So this year will be the deciding factor but id take them both well not unless Brady breaks another knee and shoulder or something....

6-10 last year. romo was 9-7 his worst year. Also romo is 31-15 as a full year starter............rodgers is 15-15

[Blue_Star_Wrecking_Crew 0]

good post. i have made this point as well. this is more detailed.

 

how its spun depends on the agenda

rodgers has two stud wrs............he has better wrs than romo.

[PATSSOX 22]

rodgers has two stud wrs............he has better wrs than romo.

 

id take Austin over both Jennings and Driver everytime Austin touches the ball i think he gonna score. Hey i like both Rodgers and Romo

[Joey Gladstone 33]

I base rankings on pro bowls, career wins, stats,

 

romo and rodgers are even in stats. romo has 2 wins for every loss while rodgers is 1 win for every loss. romo is also a probowler more often. He led a team to 13-3 record something rodgers never did. romo has also never had a losing season.

 

Everything you say on this board is completely and utterly baseless.

 

After a heavy night of drinking I release wet farts that sound like they make better points then what you post on here.

[Joey Gladstone 33]

id take Austin over both Jennings and Driver everytime Austin touches the ball i think he gonna score. Hey i like both Rodgers and Romo

 

As would I. He also failed to mention how Witten is a top-flight TE. Romo could also never win a playoff game playing with one of the greatest WR's of all time. Garcia was able to do it.

 

Garcia > Romo

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[PATSSOX 22]

As would I. He also failed to mention how Witten is a top-flight TE. Romo could also never win a playoff game playing with one of the greatest WR's of all time. Garcia was able to do it.

 

Garcia > Romo

 

 

who Irvin???? think he was retired

 

if your talking about TO he is a focking piece of GARBAGE who destroyed the Cowboys

[Blue_Star_Wrecking_Crew 0]

id take Austin over both Jennings and Driver everytime Austin touches the ball i think he gonna score. Hey i like both Rodgers and Romo

jennings and austin are about even. roy is far less than driver.

[Blue_Star_Wrecking_Crew 0]

who Irvin???? think he was retired

 

if your talking about TO he is a focking piece of GARBAGE who destroyed the Cowboys

[Joey Gladstone 33]

who Irvin???? think he was retired

 

if your talking about TO he is a focking piece of GARBAGE who destroyed the Cowboys

 

Jeff Garcia won playoff games with him.

[Houston Texans 10]

I think most would think Romo is a better qb,

And yet polls on 2 FF message boards, hundreds of FF websites and magazines, statistics, talent, and many NFL coaches and execs show Rodgers is a better QB..., huh, that's weird, isn't it?

[Houston Texans 10]

romo vs rodgers. god, i want dallas to play the packers. finally send erin rodgers packing.

And yet, it feels like this has already happened.... huh, that's weird, isn't it.

 

BTW-who won that game?

[Houston Texans 10]

good post. i have made this point as well. this is more detailed.

 

how its spun depends on the agenda

except you fail to actually take into account what is being said (or posted).

 

I'm not talking about pro-bowls when I say that Romo's 13-3 team was more talented than either team Rodgers has had in GB.

 

That Dallas' team was better on defense and the O-line that the GB team of the last 2 years. Those 2 things allowed Romo a better chance at success. I'm not saying that Dallas had 112 pro-bowlers so that proves their team was more talented. But look at the players on that Dallas defense and O-line, and then look at the players on the GB teams of the last 2 years. The O-line in GB has been mix and match with all the injuries, retirements, player movement etc, and the D was not great last year and spent the 1st half of this year adjusting to a new scheme.

 

The team around Romo doesn't negate what he did that year, however to point to that year and say "See, Romo went 13-3, he must be better," is not accurate.

[Phurfur 70]

6-10 last year. romo was 9-7 his worst year. Also romo is 31-15 as a full year starter............rodgers is 15-15

 

 

GB is rebuilding while Dallas' window is closing. I don't expect you to understand the difference.

[Blue_Star_Wrecking_Crew 0]

And yet polls on 2 FF message boards, hundreds of FF websites and magazines, statistics, talent, and many NFL coaches and execs show Rodgers is a better QB..., huh, that's weird, isn't it?

they are wrong

[Blue_Star_Wrecking_Crew 0]

GB is rebuilding while Dallas' window is closing. I don't expect you to understand the difference.

Gb went 13-3 not too long ago. how are they rebuilding now? The only rebuilding is the qb spot since they gave up favre

[Houston Texans 10]

they are wrong

 

OK, got it. You are right, and everyone else is wrong. That's a mental disease-it's called megalomania. Get help.

[jgcrawfish 232]

Rodgers, again, and it ain't even close.

[49ers_suck 0]

Rodgers, again, and it ain't even close.

see, this is the problem.

 

if you are saying the Rodgers is better than Romo "and it aint even close", then your analysis means no more than the analysis of the guy you are rippin on.

 

im ok with people thinking Rodgers is better right now. but to say he's WAY better is just a biased opinion.

[PsychoBelichickFan 0]

see, this is the problem.

 

if you are saying the Rodgers is better than Romo "and it aint even close", then your analysis means no more than the analysis of the guy you are rippin on.

 

im ok with people thinking Rodgers is better right now. but to say he's WAY better is just a biased opinion.

erin rodgers is overrated

[PsychoBelichickFan 0]

rodgers only got 237 yards and 1 lonely td against the seahawks in a huge blow out............pathetic........

 

romo is better

[jgcrawfish 232]

see, this is the problem.

 

if you are saying the Rodgers is better than Romo "and it aint even close", then your analysis means no more than the analysis of the guy you are rippin on.

 

im ok with people thinking Rodgers is better right now. but to say he's WAY better is just a biased opinion.

 

reading comprehension helps. i posted the "true" stats for everything that pimptaddy contingent has posted. rodgers wins, all counts, all stats except one. i believe rodgers also became the first guy to ever throw for 4000 yrd seasons in his first two seasons starting.

[donhaas 18]

rodgers only got 237 yards and 1 lonely td against the seahawks in a huge blow out............pathetic........

 

romo is better

 

I think his running backs scored six touchdowns today.... If he was Romo or Favre he would have audibled to easy touchdown passes but he really does not need the stats..... have you seen what he's done this season? His stats are already amazing....

 

Plus, Rodgers was out of there in the third quarter..... unlike when GB was blowing out your Dallas Lions and Romo was racking up useless garbagetime stats (foolishly risking injury) including a TD pass with 20 seconds left.... (Romo still had a crappy day!)....

 

 

HTH!!!

[49ers_suck 0]

reading comprehension helps. i posted the "true" stats for everything that pimptaddy contingent has posted. rodgers wins, all counts, all stats except one. i believe rodgers also became the first guy to ever throw for 4000 yrd seasons in his first two seasons starting.

[WhiteWonder 2,742]

is tonight the biggest game of Romo's career?

 

probably not but it has to be top 10. Win tonight and they are in.

[Houston Texans 10]

see, this is the problem.

 

if you are saying the Rodgers is better than Romo "and it aint even close", then your analysis means no more than the analysis of the guy you are rippin on.

 

im ok with people thinking Rodgers is better right now. but to say he's WAY better is just a biased opinion.

That's one of the problem with this thread. The OP (and his 473 aliases) have been posting in this thread saying how Romo is way better than Rodgers and that "Erin Rodgers is over-rated," etc, using selective stats and numbers to "prove" his point. The facts show that in the last 2 years, Rodgers is better. The biased opinion of the OP (and his STUPID posts supporting that opinion) have produced some strong responses to the contrary.

 

It is close between Rodgers and Romo, but Rodgers is better right now. Perhaps if Romo shakes the "choker" lable this year, that gap will be narrowed, but watching the two of them play, Rodgers seems cooler and (IMO) just better than Romo.

[Blue_Star_Wrecking_Crew 0]

That's one of the problem with this thread. The OP (and his 473 aliases) have been posting in this thread saying how Romo is way better than Rodgers and that "Erin Rodgers is over-rated," etc, using selective stats and numbers to "prove" his point. The facts show that in the last 2 years, Rodgers is better. The biased opinion of the OP (and his STUPID posts supporting that opinion) have produced some strong responses to the contrary.

 

It is close between Rodgers and Romo, but Rodgers is better right now. Perhaps if Romo shakes the "choker" lable this year, that gap will be narrowed, but watching the two of them play, Rodgers seems cooler and (IMO) just better than Romo.

better now? Romo has taken a two teams to the playoffs.....Rodgers has taken none. Romo has been a probowler..........romo has led a team to 13-3 and the top seed. right now my a$$

[Sho Nuff 720]

hey, i dont want a virus. cant see the stats you posted. sorry

 

A. I did not post it.

B. The text from the link was word for word the post you made. You stole it...you know it...just like you stole someone's post from fbg earlier in this thread.

 

You are the lowest of the low.

[Sho Nuff 720]

Any list that has Aaron Rodgers abouve Romo is void and null. Rodgers has failed to get GB to the playoffs yet. This has been his best season at "9" wins so far. He is an up and comer I would say Romo is about 5th and Rodger 9th or 10th in the league today. if you look at their overall numbers stats during the time they have played romo's numbers are overall far better in both qb rating and winning percentage, and yes you're right that Rodgers this year will probably lead them to a playoff berth but so will Romo this year, which will be his third time in four years doing that and romo has never had a losing season, the Packers were like 6-10 last year. I think most would think Romo is a better qb,

 

Well, Rodgers has the Packers in the playoffs now.

And pretty much all you think is anyone who disagrees with you is wrong. Well, you better get out your pad and pen to take a list...because its obvious a large majority of people out there have Rodgers rated higher.

 

Romo is not 5th...Rodgers is higher than 9th.

And no, Romo's numbers are not overall far better. You are blind...and an idiot.

 

You think most would think Romo is the better QB? Why don't you start a poll? Oh wait, you did...and it proved most think Rodgers is. I started one on a completely different site and the same results came in.

 

A majority put Rodgers > Romo.

 

Deal with it.

[Sho Nuff 720]

romo vs rodgers. god, i want dallas to play the packers. finally send erin rodgers packing.

 

Umm...they did play the Packers...Romo got shutout til a garbage time TD that did not matter.

 

Enjoy.

[Blue_Star_Wrecking_Crew 0]

Umm...they did play the Packers...Romo got shutout til a garbage time TD that did not matter.

 

Enjoy.

189 yards and 1 Td for erin

 

I think that game was pretty close.

[Sho Nuff 720]

rodgers only got 237 yards and 1 lonely td against the seahawks in a huge blow out............pathetic........

 

romo is better

 

You realize he did not play after the 3rd quarter right?

 

Too funny.

 

Troll on.

[Blue_Star_Wrecking_Crew 0]

Well, Rodgers has the Packers in the playoffs now.

And pretty much all you think is anyone who disagrees with you is wrong. Well, you better get out your pad and pen to take a list...because its obvious a large majority of people out there have Rodgers rated higher.

 

Romo is not 5th...Rodgers is higher than 9th.

And no, Romo's numbers are not overall far better. You are blind...and an idiot.

 

You think most would think Romo is the better QB? Why don't you start a poll? Oh wait, you did...and it proved most think Rodgers is. I started one on a completely different site and the same results came in.

 

A majority put Rodgers > Romo.

 

Deal with it.

 

.

 

 

 

I have dealt with it. Basically I have stated my opinion and others have stated theirs........the true intellectuals here said the guys are basically equal. I will let this get sorted out in the playoffs

[Houston Texans 10]

better now? Romo has taken a two teams to the playoffs.....Rodgers has taken none. Romo has been a probowler..........romo has led a team to 13-3 and the top seed. right now my a$$

Do you understand what NOW means? Romo's 13-3 season was 4 years ago! That's not now. "Romo HAS been a probowler" again, not now.

 

At this point in time, December 28, 2009, Rodgers is better.

 

Romo was better 4 years ago (especially since Rodgers was behine Favre), but that's not NOW.

[Houston Texans 10]

I think that game was pretty close.

Yeah, except for the score, it was.

 

189 yards and 1 Td for erin

You do realize that Tony Homo had ALMOST EXACTLY the same stats (189 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT) until GB went into prevent defense with 2 minutes left (and the game already decided), right? Oh, wait a minute, not the exact same stats, because Tony Homo threw a crucial INT (on the Packers' 1 yard line) that would have made the score 17-7 with 6 minutes left.

 

So, in this "pretty" close game, Rodgers threw for 189 yards, 1 passing TD, NO INTERCEPTIONS, & added a rushing TD.

 

Romo threw for 189 yards (and then added 62 yards in garbage time, after the game had been decided and GB went into a prevent defense) with 1 TD, and 1 CRUCIAL INTERCEPTION that prevented Dallas from having a chance to win the game.

 

Good argument you're making on this point.

[Houston Texans 10]

rodgers only got 237 yards and 1 lonely td against the seahawks in a huge blow out............pathetic........

 

romo is better

romo only got 286 yards and 1 lonely td (plus 1 INT) against the redskins in a tighter game that required him to play all 4 quarters and pass more, plus this "money in the 2 minute drill" QB ran a HORRIBLE halftime 2 minute drill where he wasted timeouts when he didn't need to, and threw the last 2 passes over the middle with no timeouts left, causing his team to get ZERO points..............pathetic..............

 

rodgers is better

 

 

 

See-anyone can do the crap that you do.

 

The fact is both TEAMS won in important games, locking up playoff spots. Neither QB had to carry his team, so it's kind of pointless to look at one game's stats and try to make a point that either QB is better based on 1 game.

[NewbieJr 541]

romo only got 286 yards and 1 lonely td (plus 1 INT) against the redskins in a tighter game that required him to play all 4 quarters and pass more, plus this "money in the 2 minute drill" QB ran a HORRIBLE halftime 2 minute drill where he wasted timeouts when he didn't need to, and threw the last 2 passes over the middle with no timeouts left, causing his team to get ZERO points..............pathetic..............

And then proceeded to cover his ass by yelling at Miles Austin for nor getting out of bounds on the last play. So not only did he run a terrible two minute drill, he pointed the finger at a teammate because he knew the cameras would be on him.

 

Embarrasing.

 

Nice 17 point effort against the redskins.