Where do Matthew Berry and the rest of the "experts" really rank?

[vjr23 2]

Interesting read. This is FantasyPros.com's "expert" accuracy rankings through 5 weeks. With all due respect to the staff at FFToday, we all know predicting fantasy performances is extremely hard and I would never claim to be better at it. However, we all know there is no such thing as an "expert" and we of course still love what they do here at FFToday. What FantasyPros.com does is track about 60 fantasy writers and analyze their projections every week for accuracy. Then they compile and update weekly. They also have a nice Start or Sit section where you can compare two players to see what the "experts" consensus is on them. I'm not affiliated with them in any way, and I still keep my loyalty and come to FFToday first and most often for my FF articles and insight (and I recommend you continue to do this too), but this is a nice site to peruse as well if you're looking for quality rankings and projections. Looks like there are some strong rankings coming out of Yahoo. Looks like the (in)famous Matthew Berry is as average as average can be, at 31 out of just about 60. And although our boys at FFToday are a disappointing 43rd and 53rd respectively, at least Krueger is top 10 at predicting DEF/ST.

 

2011 Accuracy (Weeks 1-5)

Read our summary | View weekly results

Rank Expert Name Overall RB WR QB TE DST K

1 Scott Pianowski - Yahoo 64.1% 64.2% 64.3% 68.1% 58.0% 55.2% 59.4%

2 Pat Fitzmaurice - ProFootballWeekly 63.4% 64.5% 62.6% 62.3% 63.8% 51.3% 61.5%

3 Staff Composite - Yahoo 63.3% 63.3% 63.5% 65.5% 60.1% 52.8% 59.5%

4 Josh Moore - 4for4.com 63.1% 64.4% 64.4% 63.4% 55.6% N/A N/A

5 John Paulsen - The Fantasy Shrink 63.0% 61.9% 64.4% 65.1% 59.7% 54.2% 54.0%

6 Kevin Hanson - EDSFootball 62.9% 63.6% 64.8% 62.7% 55.9% 47.7% 47.9%

7 Sigmund Bloom - FootballGuys 62.7% 64.3% 62.7% 61.2% 60.1% N/A N/A

8 Ken Zalis - Fans Fantasy Football 62.7% 63.5% 63.8% 64.2% 55.3% 56.2% 59.7%

9 Mike Woellert - FantasyFootball.com 62.6% 61.9% 65.1% 61.6% 58.6% 52.5% 53.1%

10 Andy Behrens - Yahoo 62.3% 60.1% 63.7% 63.6% 63.1% 50.5% 57.5%

11 Brad Evans - Yahoo 62.3% 63.9% 62.3% 62.1% 57.5% 49.1% 57.8%

12 Michael Fabiano - NFL.com 62.1% 62.3% 65.0% 61.5% 54.2% 54.0% 48.9%

13 Chet Gresham - Razzball.com 62.0% 62.2% 62.8% 66.0% 53.9% 54.7% 54.7%

14 Brandon Funston - Yahoo 62.0% 63.0% 61.8% 64.6% 56.1% 51.1% 58.4%

15 Gregg Rosenthal - Rotoworld 61.8% 61.9% 62.2% 65.7% 55.5% 52.4% 55.1%

16 Jeff Ratcliffe - Pro Football Focus 61.8% 61.6% 63.7% 64.1% 54.3% 48.9% 56.8%

17 Staff Composite - NFL.com 61.6% 62.7% 63.0% 61.1% 55.3% 54.4% 48.0%

18 Eric Karabell - ESPN 61.6% 63.2% 63.9% 63.4% 48.0% 52.2% 48.8%

19 Patrick White - Fantasy Sharks 61.6% 61.8% 63.5% 62.9% 53.8% 42.8% 43.6%

20 Ken Moody - Dynasty League Football 61.6% 63.0% 64.3% 60.7% 50.7% N/A 40.9%

21 Walter Cherepinsky - Walter Football 61.5% 62.7% 61.5% 60.7% 59.4% 47.3% N/A

22 Derek Lofland - FFManiaxs 61.5% 59.5% 64.7% 63.3% 56.3% N/A N/A

23 Staff Rankings - FFToolbox 61.5% 62.8% 60.8% 66.2% 53.2% 41.7% 51.4%

24 Christopher Harris - ESPN 61.5% 61.1% 63.3% 63.5% 54.8% 50.3% 50.0%

25 Sablich Brothers - The New York Times 61.4% 62.5% 63.1% 62.2% 52.0% 51.9% 61.5%

26 Kevin Roberts - NFL Soup 61.3% 60.3% 64.2% 64.0% 52.8% 55.4% 65.4%

27 David Dodds - FootballGuys 61.3% 61.6% 62.6% 60.7% 57.3% 45.8% 59.0%

28 Staff Composite - ESPN 61.1% 62.9% 63.6% 59.2% 51.4% 53.0% 50.8%

29 Staff Rankings - Fantasy Football Freaks 61.1% 62.6% 65.5% 62.7% 42.2% 43.8% 48.9%

30 Russ Bliss - Fantasy Football Starters 61.0% 60.9% 62.1% 60.1% 59.5% 52.7% 48.1%

31 Matthew Berry - ESPN 60.9% 61.9% 62.4% 61.1% 53.6% 55.4% 48.6%

32 Roger Rotter - USA Today 60.9% 59.0% 61.5% 64.7% 59.8% 36.4% 45.5%

33 Alessandro Miglio - Pro Football Focus 60.8% 58.4% 62.1% 65.7% 57.9% 47.3% 48.8%

34 Dave Dameshek - NFL.com 60.8% 61.0% 60.6% 63.8% 56.6% 56.4% 46.8%

35 Tristan Cockcroft - ESPN 60.7% 62.6% 63.3% 60.6% 48.2% 48.2% 46.5%

36 Jamey Eisenberg - CBS Sports 60.7% 62.8% 61.2% 58.8% 55.2% 47.9% 58.6%

37 Adam Rank - NFL.com 60.5% 60.4% 63.3% 61.5% 52.0% 52.8% 51.1%

38 Dave Richard - CBS Sports 60.5% 62.7% 62.7% 57.9% 50.9% 51.5% 48.8%

39 Site Rankings - FantasyFootballNerd 60.4% 59.8% 64.1% 62.7% 49.2% 48.5% 55.8%

40 Matt Smith - NFL.com 60.1% 62.3% 63.1% 57.4% 48.3% 49.6% 40.4%

41 Ryan Lester - Lester's Legends 60.0% 60.3% 63.3% 59.5% 50.8% 47.9% 37.3%

42 Staff Rankings - Fantazzle 60.0% 63.3% 59.0% 60.1% 52.6% 52.1% 47.1%

43 Mike Krueger - FFToday 59.6% 62.0% 59.5% 62.4% 48.7% 55.2% 51.3%

44 Staff Rankings - Chinstrap Ninjas 59.3% 59.2% 63.5% 58.1% 49.9% 49.8% 49.5%

45 Jason Sarney - Fantasy Phenoms 59.3% 60.2% 58.8% 62.6% 53.6% 26.2% 42.6%

46 Mike Clay - Pro Football Focus 59.1% 61.5% 59.1% 58.6% 52.4% 55.3% 54.5%

47 Site Projections - numberFire 58.9% 62.6% 59.1% 55.7% 51.2% 52.6% 49.3%

48 Paul Greco - FantasyPros911 58.6% 60.0% 60.6% 58.0% 49.4% 50.9% 55.9%

49 Keet Bailey - NFL Soup 58.2% 58.6% 62.7% 60.1% 42.2% 47.4% 48.7%

50 Anthony Perri - Insider Football 58.1% 59.7% 61.0% 56.3% 47.8% 38.9% 35.9%

51 Robb Perkins - Fantasy Football Trader 57.9% 57.8% 61.4% 56.1% 50.6% 52.8% 55.0%

52 Staff Rankings - KFFL 57.6% 57.4% 60.8% 56.2% 51.3% 46.1% 38.2%

53 Chris Eakin - FFToday 57.2% 57.2% 59.6% 57.8% 49.9% 44.8% 46.0%

54 Site Projections - scoutPRO 56.3% 55.1% 57.2% 60.0% 52.3% 39.1% 48.3%

55 Staff Projections - FantasySharks 55.3% 57.0% 54.6% 56.8% 50.2% 59.3% 46.2%

56 Smitty - Fantasy Football Xtreme 55.2% 52.7% 57.8% 61.6% 46.8% N/A N/A

57 Staff Projections - SI.com 53.4% 54.4% 56.7% 54.8% 39.7% 46.3% 37.8%

58 Staff Projections - WhatIfSports 51.6% 54.3% 55.3% 47.2% 38.9% 34.8% 35.9%

 

Cleaner version of above: http://www.fantasypros.com/nfl/accuracy/index.php

[WhiteWonder 2,982]

so what you're saying is yahoo seems to be the place to go?

 

i use cbs, i like jamey eisenberg's analysis for some reason.

[TwentyFourSeven 23]

so what you're saying is yahoo seems to be the place to go?

 

That's what I got out of it!

[kutulu 1,722]

2 Pat Fitzmaurice - ProFootballWeekly

 

I always check out Fitz's rankings.

[thePRO 78]

Cool find! Thanks dude! I'm going to use this to decide on Best or Mendenhall this week lol! They both seem to be around 16/17 ugh..

[IMMensaMind 462]

I thought a lot more about Matthew Berry before the article that claimed that drafting Vick and Gates will win you a championship in 10 man leagues.

[Kent 228]

I ignore everything CBS says.

 

Looks like that was right. CBS is always a week behind for projections. They had AJ Green poorly projected for 4 weeks.

 

Never paid attention to Yahoo. May start reading what they have to say.

[SaintsInDome2006 748]

Berry currently coming in at No. 93.

 

http://www.fantasypros.com/nfl/accuracy/?loggedin

[plasma george 63]

He's a little Jewish nerd that never sniffed the green grass of a Football field, compiles data and analysis to predict statistics.

 

I totally believe those of us that walked and played the game, do have insight into talent that the numbers nerds don't have.

 

Problem is this is Fantasy Football is a game of statistics, so you can do well analyzing stats from a computer, and never going out in the sun.

[BufordT 444]

The above list is from 2011. So far this year, none of the yahoo guys are in the Top 10. Pretty interesting link, though. Shows the Top 20 "experts" from year 2009-present. Yahoo's Scott Pianowski's name seems to be listed most often in the Top 10. The Score's Justin Boone has been very consistent for the past 3 years.

[SLM827 4]

I'm a Mike Clay and John Paulsen fan myself

[SaintsInDome2006 748]

Rank Expert Name Overall* QB RB WR TE K DST 1 Justin Boone

The Score 60.6% 67.9% 61.5% 57.8% 57.2% 62.4% 46.5% 2 John Paulsen

4for4.com 59.5% 68.5% 60.0% 56.6% 54.8% n/a n/a 3 Jake Ciely

RotoExperts 58.8% 65.8% 59.6% 57.5% 53.1% 57.0% 43.5% 4 Nick Raducanu

ProjectRoto 58.7% 65.0% 58.3% 58.6% 54.9% 58.1% 48.4% 5 Bryan Fontaine

Pro Football Focus 58.6% 65.6% 57.8% 56.9% 57.1% n/a 56.0% 6 Scott Pianowski

Yahoo! Sports 58.6% 68.5% 56.7% 56.7% 57.5% 51.1% 45.9% 7 Ken Zalis

Pressbox 58.4% 66.4% 58.8% 57.3% 51.5% 58.4% 44.6% 8 Nathan Miller

Revelation Sports 58.4% 71.4% 59.9% 56.4% 44.1% 52.3% 55.3% 9 Site Rankings

Bloomberg Sports 58.4% 62.2% 62.2% 53.9% 54.1% 50.5% 52.0% 10 Terrance Bridgett

ProjectRoto 58.2% 63.7% 57.7% 57.4% 56.5% 53.0% 41.9% 11 Austin Lee

FootballGuys 58.1% 65.6% 56.7% 58.2% 54.3% 58.9% 48.6% 12 Adam Pfeifer

ProjectRoto 58.1% 63.7% 59.5% 57.4% 50.2% 51.7% 48.7% 13 Marc Caviglia

Bruno Boys 58.0% 65.5% 58.9% 55.8% 53.5% 49.8% 47.9% 14 Kelly Smelser

Punch Drunk Wonderland 58.0% 67.4% 57.1% 56.6% 53.5% 59.4% 50.8% 15 Adrian Pereira

eDraft 58.0% 64.9% 57.5% 54.6% 58.6% 50.4% 45.3% 16 Neil Parker

Fantasy Sports LR 57.9% 68.1% 57.6% 56.5% 51.3% 52.9% 45.4% 17 Nate Hodges

Pro Football Focus 57.9% 61.3% 57.0% 56.9% 59.4% 58.8% 51.4% 18 Jeff Ratcliffe

Pro Football Focus 57.8% 63.9% 59.8% 56.4% 50.7% 57.3% 46.8% 19 Matthew Hill

Fantasy Team Advice 57.7% 62.5% 56.5% 57.0% 57.2% n/a n/a 20 Sablich Brothers

The New York Times 57.7% 67.9% 58.7% 54.1% 51.8% 53.9% 46.0% 21 Scott Spratt

Pro Football Focus 57.6% 59.7% 58.7% 55.4% 59.0% 55.9% 42.2% 22 Kyle Wachtel

Forensic Fantasy 57.6% 68.2% 57.5% 54.0% 54.6% 61.0% 47.6% 23 Walter Cherepinsky

WalterFootball 57.6% 62.7% 59.0% 53.3% 57.1% n/a 49.7% 24 Patrick Thorman

Pro Football Focus 57.5% 64.7% 60.1% 55.2% 49.1% 54.8% 44.1% 25 Jason Longfellow

Razzball 57.5% 67.6% 56.5% 59.2% 46.4% 62.3% 48.3% 26 Jamey Eisenberg

CBS Sports 57.4% 62.4% 57.6% 58.5% 49.3% 48.1% 42.5% 27 Mike Clay

Pro Football Focus 57.3% 59.6% 60.7% 53.1% 55.7% 55.3% 57.3% 28 Andy Behrens

Yahoo! Sports 57.2% 59.4% 55.4% 58.5% 56.7% 49.2% 48.5% 29 Tommy Rowan

Juan Elway 57.2% 69.4% 57.3% 56.9% 43.2% n/a 54.1% 30 Site Projections

NumberFire 57.1% 64.7% 57.2% 56.8% 50.5% 58.3% 51.1% 31 C.D. Carter

XN Sports 57.1% 63.4% 58.7% 56.1% 48.8% n/a 49.8% 32 Brad Evans

Yahoo! Sports 57.1% 65.8% 55.1% 60.5% 46.5% 43.5% 46.8% 33 David Dodds

FootballGuys 57.1% 64.5% 59.7% 53.9% 48.5% 55.7% 44.2% 34 Ben Standig

CSN Washington 57.0% 67.8% 57.5% 55.3% 47.9% 56.5% 46.9% 35 Chet Gresham

The Fake Football 57.0% 68.4% 59.2% 53.1% 48.5% 59.7% 49.9% 36 Brent Namejko

Fantasy Smack Talk 57.0% 68.3% 55.8% 54.6% 52.6% 51.1% 47.1% 37 Ryan Noonan

The Fantasy Fix 57.0% 62.8% 55.8% 60.0% 48.2% 55.8% 52.9% 38 Michael Pichan

Fantasy Alarm 57.0% 62.5% 57.9% 55.8% 52.9% 56.9% 38.0% 39 John Halpin

Fox Sports 57.0% 63.0% 56.3% 57.1% 51.4% 55.6% 53.0% 40 Ryan Hodge

ProjectRoto 56.9% 65.2% 57.1% 54.5% 53.2% 57.1% 52.3% 41 Tozzi Brothers

Legion Report 56.9% 66.6% 54.1% 54.9% 58.1% 54.5% 45.0% 42 Alan Harrison

The Fantasy Fix 56.9% 63.1% 56.5% 53.9% 57.8% 59.4% 47.5% 43 Dawgmatica

Pyromaniac 56.9% 63.9% 59.2% 56.6% 44.5% n/a n/a 44 Mike Tagliere

Tags Fantasy Football 56.8% 62.0% 58.7% 55.0% 51.0% n/a n/a 45 Alessandro Miglio

FootballGuys 56.8% 68.4% 52.1% 54.2% 60.8% 64.3% 49.4% 46 James Hatfield

Hatty Waiver Wire Guru 56.7% 62.7% 58.5% 55.4% 49.4% 53.0% 53.5% 47 Chris Heil

ProjectRoto 56.7% 59.2% 58.4% 57.1% 50.0% n/a n/a 48 Jason Willan

Gridiron Experts 56.7% 69.8% 54.7% 53.2% 55.2% 55.8% 45.7% 49 Joseph Dolan

Fantasy Guru 56.6% 63.0% 56.9% 55.2% 53.0% 44.0% n/a 50 Jeff Boggis

Fantasy Football Empire 56.6% 67.0% 57.1% 52.3% 53.4% 62.9% 56.9% 51 Dave Major

XN Sports 56.5% 67.6% 54.8% 55.7% 51.3% 53.7% 43.8% 52 Tony Mauriello

ProjectRoto 56.5% 64.2% 55.5% 56.1% 53.0% 45.5% n/a 53 Staff

Roto Analysis 56.5% 67.1% 50.9% 58.4% 55.3% 52.1% 46.3% 54 Sean Morris

Bruno Boys 56.4% 62.1% 60.5% 53.1% 48.4% 50.9% 43.4% 55 Kevin Roberts

Breaking Football 56.4% 65.1% 52.8% 57.1% 56.8% 56.4% 45.6% 56 Brandon Funston

Yahoo! Sports 56.4% 59.2% 53.1% 61.5% 51.4% 60.2% 58.8% 57 Micah James

FFMagicMan 56.3% 59.7% 55.8% 55.2% 58.4% 56.2% 45.5% 58 Dalton Del Don

Yahoo! Sports 56.3% 60.7% 56.5% 59.1% 46.2% 58.6% 51.9% 59 Jeff Brubach

The Fake Football 56.3% 64.8% 55.1% 54.8% 54.0% 46.1% 41.6% 60 Jody Smith

Gridiron Experts 56.3% 64.6% 57.6% 54.7% 47.7% 58.8% 50.8% 61 Sigmund Bloom

FootballGuys 56.3% 59.5% 55.5% 55.9% 56.3% n/a n/a 62 Brett Talley

The Fantasy Fix 56.2% 57.9% 56.1% 55.4% 58.4% 59.8% 43.2% 63 Tom Poisal

Top Tier Football 56.2% 61.7% 58.2% 53.6% 50.3% 50.6% 47.3% 64 Des Bieler

The Washington Post 56.2% 65.8% 55.4% 55.0% 51.6% 58.4% 45.0% 65 Joe Bond

Fantasy Six Pack 56.2% 67.3% 54.9% 55.2% 50.8% 52.6% 50.2% 66 Staff Rankings

DavidGonos.com 56.2% 63.8% 56.6% 57.7% 44.8% 52.6% 48.6% 67 Jon Collins

Fantasy Sports LR 56.2% 57.6% 56.7% 56.5% 53.1% 57.1% 52.2% 68 Eric Karabell

ESPN 56.0% 61.5% 53.0% 59.8% 51.0% 52.7% 45.0% 69 Sean Beazley

EDSFootball 56.0% 61.2% 53.0% 57.6% 54.2% 56.0% 52.1% 70 Bill Enright

FFChamps 56.0% 68.9% 55.1% 56.4% 42.1% 61.4% 48.1% 71 Pat Fitzmaurice

The Football Girl 55.9% 61.4% 56.6% 56.4% 47.3% 55.2% 42.1% 72 Christopher Harris

ESPN 55.9% 64.0% 52.8% 58.0% 50.9% 37.4% 46.5% 73 Walton Spurlin

FantasySharks 55.9% 63.5% 53.0% 57.3% 52.5% 46.1% 51.2% 74 R.C. Fischer

Fantasy Football Metrics 55.8% 60.7% 59.0% 50.7% 53.4% n/a 51.4% 75 Mike Harmon

Swollen Dome 55.8% 61.7% 56.5% 55.4% 50.5% 50.0% 45.5% 76 Ross Miles

Pro Football Focus 55.8% 65.9% 57.0% 53.3% 48.7% 66.0% 44.8% 77 Dan Clasgens

Get Sports Info 55.8% 62.1% 54.2% 57.8% 49.3% 59.7% 46.0% 78 Davis Mattek

Sports Wunderkind 55.8% 66.8% 54.9% 56.8% 46.1% n/a n/a 79 Staff Rankings

2MugsFF 55.8% 62.7% 54.4% 56.5% 50.3% 49.8% 49.6% 80 Dan Yanotchko

EDSFootball 55.8% 59.0% 56.0% 57.2% 48.0% 59.8% 50.4% 81 Patrick Daugherty

Rotoworld 55.7% 67.0% 55.1% 53.6% 49.5% 49.6% 41.2% 82 R.J. White

Fantasy Football Cafe 55.7% 64.0% 54.5% 54.0% 53.9% 54.7% 48.1% 83 Jeff Paur

RTSports 55.6% 62.5% 52.1% 56.2% 55.8% 48.9% 45.7% 84 The FFGhost

Dynasty League Football 55.6% 61.8% 54.6% 56.2% 51.1% 52.7% 51.6% 85 Nathan Jahnke

Pro Football Focus 55.6% 66.3% 59.2% n/a 55.9% 55.6% n/a 86 Kevin Hanson

EDSFootball 55.6% 60.1% 58.7% 56.6% 40.6% 58.0% 43.7% 87 Greg Smith

The Fake Football 55.6% 64.3% 55.4% 54.4% 49.8% 57.1% 40.3% 88 Mike Krueger

FFToday 55.5% 55.7% 56.7% 54.6% 54.1% 42.0% 49.3% 89 Ryan Rufe

RotoBaller 55.5% 69.0% 51.0% 54.5% 55.4% 53.0% 40.8% 90 Mike Rigz

Gridiron Experts 55.4% 62.1% 56.0% 51.5% 55.3% 57.5% 49.8% 91 Staff Rankings

FFToolbox 55.4% 62.3% 58.5% 49.7% 53.9% 61.4% 39.4% 92 Maurile Tremblay

FootballGuys 55.4% 55.6% 57.6% 50.5% 58.8% 55.3% 45.4% 93 Matthew Berry

ESPN 55.4% 64.7% 53.5% 55.5% 50.1% 59.8% 50.5% 94 Marcus Grant

NFL.com 55.3% 61.6% 53.8% 55.4% 52.5% 44.7% 44.3% 95 Scott Cullen

TSN 55.3% 64.0% 51.2% 58.4% 49.5% 58.7% 51.6% 96 Raju Byfield

Win My Fantasy League 55.2% 64.3% 53.3% 53.3% 54.9% n/a n/a 97 Rich Hribar

XN Sports 55.1% 62.4% 58.6% 52.9% 44.8% n/a 54.7% 98 KJ

Fantasy Team Advice 55.1% 58.7% 54.9% 52.5% 57.2% n/a n/a 99 Eric Mack

Bleacher Report 55.1% 63.5% 57.1% 50.6% 50.2% 62.9% 48.1% 100 Salvatore Stefanile

XN Sports 55.1% 66.7% 52.4% 56.8% 46.7% 58.3% 45.3%

[SaintsInDome2006 748]

The above is current in-season.

[jdon 28]

He's a little Jewish nerd that never sniffed the green grass of a Football field, compiles data and analysis to predict statistics.

 

I totally believe those of us that walked and played the game, do have insight into talent that the numbers nerds don't have.

 

Problem is this is Fantasy Football is a game of statistics, so you can do well analyzing stats from a computer, and never going out in the sun.

 

wow dude. you must of been popular in high school... I can't remember the last time I encountered antisemitism and elitist anti-nerd behavior on a fantasy website.

pathetic bro pathetic.

[TheGiantJets 18]

I don't care for K and D/ST rankings. I'm too lazy to compile and sort but i wonder who are the top at predicting QB,RB,WR and TE.

[iam90sbaby 2,727]

I don't really pay attention to any fantasy experts, but I do enjoy listening to Dave Dameshek, some of the things he says are hilarious.

[GobbleDog 1,014]

43 Mike Krueger - FFToday 59.6% 62.0% 59.5% 62.4% 48.7% 55.2% 51.3%

 

53 Chris Eakin - FFToday 57.2% 57.2% 59.6% 57.8% 49.9% 44.8% 46.0%