Lesser of 4 evils which RB would you keep ?

[BoxFullofJoel 3]

Need some input for you guys. I am in my first keeper league and I have an RB problem. I can keep 5 OFF starters

 

I am keeping :

QB Big Ben

WR Nicks, Roddy, Marshall

 

MY RB are as follows

 

Reggie Bush

J-Stew

D-Williams

Hills

 

How do I get out of the suck?

[Frozenbeernuts 1,654]

It is actually a keeper league but some say mine is a keeper league so who am I to argue.

 

Hmm. I would say R Bush is your best bet for production this year. He is in a contract year and probably the last big contract he will ever have a chance to get. If you are looking for a guy to keep for more than a year I would go J Stew.

[jgcrawfish 232]

It is actually a keeper league but some say mine is a keeper league so who am I to argue.

 

Hmm. I would say R Bush is your best bet for production this year. He is in a contract year and probably the last big contract he will ever have a chance to get. If you are looking for a guy to keep for more than a year I would go J Stew.

 

Exactly what I was going to say. Heck, I might keep Stewart just for production this year over Bush.

[Kent 228]

I'd keep JStew.

[The Moz 69]

If it's a keeper league and thats your choices it's a no brainer -- Bush - he's the only starter there

[Matt Mueller 146]

Both Bush and J Stew might be valued higher than Roth by some owners for various reasons. They have a higher startup rankings in some places. Here: http://dynastyleaguefootball.com/rankings/dynasty-top-400-rankings

 

I might look to keep both, and either deal one, or a wr, for a better qb than Roth.

[Portis26 0]

Both Bush and J Stew might be valued higher than Roth by some owners for various reasons. They have a higher startup rankings in some places.

 

I might look to keep both, and either deal one, or a wr, for a better qb than Roth.

 

X2 and dump The Rapist

 

.

[Kopy 497]

Exactly what I was going to say. Heck, I might keep Stewart just for production this year over Bush.

My thoughts exactly

[Raider 84 29]

Stewart!

[Super Cubs 134]

How do I get out of the suck?

You trade. Pair up 2 of your WR for a better option at RB. Trade picks for a better RB. Trade keeper spot for a up grade at RB or picks. Honestly you can get by keeping only 4 players and still be where are are right now.

[steelers2101 7]

Keep both J Stew and Bush and let Big Ben go.

 

It's actually a no brainer.

[BoxFullofJoel 3]

I would like to keep my WR's intact since I start 3. Dumping Ben is an interesting Idea

[b0younce 0]

R Bush and J Stew. Big Ben is garbage, dump him.

[jgcrawfish 232]

Keep both J Stew and Bush and let Big Ben go.

 

It's actually a no brainer.

 

This is actually not a bad suggestion, and an interesting one considering it came from a Steelers fan. Setting aside my Steeler hat as well, it might be the best course of action but it would depend a lot on what the pool of QB's looks like. It also depends on how your league handles teams that don't carry four over (if that's allowed at all). My league is changing to a 1 player keeper for the 1st time this year AND adding two new teams. We're trying to determine what to do with those two new teams and what to do if someone doesn't designate a keeper. My preference would be to wait a year on the keeper part, but I suggested doing a supplemental 1-round draft with a separate random order for those two teams and anybody else that doesn't designate a keeper, kind of a private 1st round. Then draft order would reset for all 12 teams and regular draft would begin. It sort of depends on how this league handles it I guess.

[BoxFullofJoel 3]

I have the second pick in the draft too so I might be able to draft a decent QB. I am targeting Richardson though if available.

[montana 89]

Keep JStew over DWill?

Interesting.