Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Mike Honcho

Grade Your Teams Draft - 2016

Recommended Posts

All right it's that time of the year again, Grade the 2016 draft. Did your team improve, tread water or go backwards? You are the professor, grade the team how ever you like.

2016 NFL Draft


Found this chart/article that details the chance a player sticks with a team by round. How long does the average draft pick stick around(Charted by round)?

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Green Bay Packers

1.27 -  DL, Kenny Clark, UCLA: Has been the best player on the Packers defense the last two years.   Has always been solid against the run, nearly impossible to displace and has gotten better and better in the passing game.  Rates as one of the best interior linemen in the game and one of Thompson's last really good picks. Grade A+

2.17 -  OL, Jason Spriggs, Indiana: Was drafted as an athletic, quick-footed tackle who needed to develop his strength.   First two years in the league IF he played, he got absolutely steam-rolled.  Bulked up for his third year in the league and lost a step, and was constantly beat by speed rushers.   Thompson traded up to get him for a return you would expect from a 6th rounder. Grade F

3.25 - LB, Kyler Fackrell, Utah State: Older player(turned 25 as a rookie) drafted for his athleticism and potential as a pass rusher.   Was expected to go higher in the draft, so appeared to be excellent value in round 3.  Barely saw the field his first two season, started 7 games in his third and led the Packers in sacks.  Sack totals are great, but odd in that when he doesn't get a sack, he rarely generates pressure. In the run game he misses way too many tackles.  At this point, he looks to be rotational player on passing downs.  Grade C-

4.33 - LB, Blake Martinez, Stanford: Was drafted as a capable inside LB, and he's a capable inside LB.   Grades strongly against the run, pass rush, play recognition, but his speed makes him a liability in when asked to cover.   He's a starting ILB drafted at the end of the 4th round.  Grade B

4.39 - DL, Dean Lowry, Northwestern: Added to the squad to as a five technique with great size and upside.   Has played in every game since he was drafted and really stepped up last season.   Stout run defender, who can generate pressure in the pass game.  Ideally, he's the 4th DL, the guy who comes in and gives a breather, part-time starter behind the Clarks, Daniels and  ???  Look for the team to try and find ??? in this draft and Lowry to be good rotational player.  Grade B

5.26 - WR, Trevor Davis, California: He was drafted to be a returner and that looks to be his ceiling. Has done next to nothing as a WR, but has some good moments as a punt returner.   Couldn't stay healthy in year three and only saw 2 games.  Could be back for a 4th year for his ST abilities and rookie contract. Grade D+

6.25 - OL, Kyle Murphy, Stanford:  Inactive most of year 1, started at both tackle spots in first 3 games of year two before foot injury ended his season. Placed on IR at the start of the 2018 season before being released after the last game. Just not strong enough and injury prone.  Grade D-

This draft provided one pro-bowl player at the end of round 1, Clark and starter Martinez(41 starts out of 48).   In addition you got two rotational guys who are above average for backups.  Despite seeming like they stole Fackrell in the third, he's about a 4th round talent.   The big misses hurt as they both were on the O'line and the team just keeps getting older and older without adequately replacing the departures.   On other teams, 4 capable players from one draft would be a pretty good haul, but this was still under the Ted Thompson regime so this is the entirety of new contributors from the 2016 year---so basically the team was just treading water.  

Overall C+

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tennessee Titans

1st round - jack Conklin, RT

Played very well in 2017 until blowing out his knee in the divisional round. Probably came back too soon, and didn't play as well last season. Have high hopes he bounces back strong. B+


2nd round - Kevin dodd, edge

Bust. Sucked. Never did sh!t. Off the team. F

Derrick Henry, RB

Looked like an unstoppable Force late last season. Shoring up the interior ol should help that continue. Will be a run heavy team and hes gonna get the shot at being the bell cow. B-

Austin johnson, DL

Mediocre. Likely to be replaced in this draft, but has been a decent rotational guy. C-

3rd round -

Kevin Byard, FS

Steal of the draft. An all pro caliber guy in the third. A+

Overall... B-


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Steelers selected in the 25th spot in 2016.

Round 1  Corner Artie Burns.  Can't cover and a poor tackler.  Lacks heart.  Competing with Jarvis Jones as GM Kevin Colbert''s worst first round pick in 19 years.  The next DB taken in the 2016 draft was 13 picks later Miami selecting pro bowl Xavien Howard.  After week 6 last season Burns played only 15 snaps the rest of the way and not due to injury.  Highly unlikely the Steelers pick up his 5th year option.  Grade F-

 Round 2  Safety Sean Davis.  Led team in tackles the past two seasons.  Improved last season after switching from strong safety to free safety which was his natural position at Maryland.  Far from elite, but above average.  Grade C+

Round 3  DT Jevon Hargrave.  The best pick of a crappy draft for the Steelers.  Played in every game last season, starting 14.  He has improved each season.  Steelers are solid in the interior of the defense with Cameron Heyward, Stephon Tuitt, and Hargrave.  Grade B

Round 4  OT Jerald Hawkins.  Injured for 2/3 of career.  Missed all of 2018 with a torn quad.  I doubt he sees the field much even if healthy in 2019 if he even makes the final roster.  Grade F 

Round 6  LB Travis Freeney.  Released in 2016 and signed to the practice squad.  Saints claimed him but he never played for them.  Last seen playing in the AAF.  Grade F  

Round 7  WR  Demaracus Ayers.  Cut before the 2017 season.  Last seen playing in the AAF  Grade F 

Round 7   LB Tyler Matakevich.  Played just 133 snaps in 3 years.  Decent special teamer, good locker room guy.  Lacks athleticism to compete at this level.  Grade D 

Steelers would of been better off auto drafting in 2016.

Final Grade F

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this