All-time playoff quarterback winning percentages

[49ers_suck 0]

Yes we are. The list is in the original post. You brought up Aikman. He's already on the list.

you and eagles queen compared mcchunk to Romo. i then called your mcchunk, and raised with Aikman.

[parrot 789]

Are we talking about the same guy who picked up a ridiculously stupid 15 yard unsportsmanlike conduct penalty yesterday in a 12 point playoff game with three minutes left to play, turning a third and one into a third and sixteen, ultimately leading to a punt?

 

That's some fine "clutch" QB play there Lou.

[NewbieJr 541]

you and eagles queen compared mcchunk to Romo. i then called your mcchunk, and raised with Aikman.

Yeah, I know. And I congratulated you on your team's quarterback from fifteen years ago.

 

If I were you, I'd congratulate everyone on this list, and then worry about what the Cowboys are going to do going forward.

 

 

 

Moral of the story is, if you want to throw around the "choke" word, it's probably best if your own team's quarterback is not the worst example of a choke artist in modern NFL history.

 

itsatip

[Eagles Green 34]

Are we talking about the same guy who picked up a ridiculously stupid 15 yard unsportsmanlike conduct penalty yesterday in a 12 point playoff game with three minutes left to play, turning a third and one into a third and sixteen, ultimately leading to a punt?

 

That's some fine "clutch" QB play there Lou.

:cough; Scoreboard :cough:

[NewbieJr 541]

Are we talking about the same guy who picked up a ridiculously stupid 15 yard unsportsmanlike conduct penalty yesterday in a 12 point playoff game with three minutes left to play, turning a third and one into a third and sixteen, ultimately leading to a punt?

 

That's some fine "clutch" QB play there Lou.

Yup. That's the guy. I bet Cassel saw it, too. Sitting in a recliner somewhere.

 

Bwahahaha

[49ers_suck 0]

Yeah, I know. And I congratulated you on your team's quarterback from fifteen years ago.

 

If I were you, I'd congratulate everyone on this list, and then worry about what the Cowboys are going to do going forward.

Moral of the story is, if you want to throw around the "choke" word, it's probably best if your own team's quarterback is not the worst example of a choke artist in modern NFL history.

 

itsatip

ok, fair enough. but we're talking ALL-TIME here. we'll just see what the record books have to say about mcchunk when it's all said and done. i bet it'll say something like "pretty good QB, couldnt win the big one."

[Durtee 0]

Average teams don't finish in the top 8 in the NFL is offense, scoring offense, defense, and scoring defense. Their defense is one of the top 3 in the NFL right up there with Pittsburgh and Baltimore, and they're playing better than ever right now. Their offense still finished in the top 8 in the nfl in offense and scoring, and that's in spite of some very poor play calling games by Reid. I just think you're underestimating the talent on this team. They absolutely took it to the Giants yesterday. Everyone thought the Giants offensive line and running game could dominate an undersized Eagles front 7, but that was hardly the case. And while McNabb wasn't spectacular, he played 2 quarters throwing in very windy conditions against a very good defense at GIANT stadium. He still finished over 50% passing, led 4 scoring drives, and made some very crucial 3rd down conversions. Did you see the play he made on 3rd and 20?, that was vintage McNabb. He is doing a very nice job of escaping any pressure and putting the ball where it needs to go. Don't sleep on this Eagles team. They got all the momentum and are playing as well or better than anyone.

 

I think this is why guys like phillybear are hating on the Eagles today. The Eagles took it to the Giants yesterday? That would imply that they dominated that game statistically.

 

Total Yards- NYG 307 PHI 276

Passing Yards- NYG 169 PHI 217

Rushing Yards- NYG 138 PHI 59

First Downs- NYG 16 PHI 20

Time of Possession- NYG 30:15 PHI 29:45

 

Looks like a pretty evenly played game to me. The difference was a few plays in the game. INT by Manning that gave the Eagles the ball 1st and Goal. Poor play calling by the Giants in the 4th quarter and the biggest difference was that McNabb made big throws when he needed to and Eli didn't. Hardely a domination by either team.

[NewbieJr 541]

I think this is why guys like phillybear are hating on the Eagles today. The Eagles took it to the Giants yesterday? That would imply that they dominated that game statistically.

 

Total Yards- NYG 307 PHI 276

Passing Yards- NYG 169 PHI 217

Rushing Yards- NYG 138 PHI 59

First Downs- NYG 16 PHI 20

Time of Possession- NYG 30:15 PHI 29:45

 

Looks like a pretty evenly played game to me. The difference was a few plays in the game. INT by Manning that gave the Eagles the ball 1st and Goal. Poor play calling by the Giants in the 4th quarter and the biggest difference was that McNabb made big throws when he needed to and Eli didn't. Hardely a domination by either team.

I certainly don't think the Eagles dominated the game. The Eagles scored touchdowns with their opportunities and the Giants were held to field goals. That's very often the difference when two equal teams play.

[49ers_suck 0]

I think this is why guys like phillybear are hating on the Eagles today. The Eagles took it to the Giants yesterday? That would imply that they dominated that game statistically.

 

Total Yards- NYG 307 PHI 276

Passing Yards- NYG 169 PHI 217

Rushing Yards- NYG 138 PHI 59

First Downs- NYG 16 PHI 20

Time of Possession- NYG 30:15 PHI 29:45

 

Looks like a pretty evenly played game to me. The difference was a few plays in the game. INT by Manning that gave the Eagles the ball 1st and Goal. Poor play calling by the Giants in the 4th quarter and the biggest difference was that McNabb made big throws when he needed to and Eli didn't. Hardely a domination by either team.

honestly, the difference in the game was manning's poor play under pressure. and trust me, i know it when i see it. his play reminded me of a Romo stinker.

[phillybear 366]

I hate miserable fat people.

 

4 straight years of winning playoff games, but only one SB appearance? I guess Hasslehoff is a choker. He sure choked at Lambeau with a pick 6 in OT.

Mcnabb>>>>>>Hasslefuck

 

That's why Mcnabb is playing football next week.

CANKLE

 

4 straight NFC championship games, but only one SB apperance? I guess McNabb is a choker. He sure choked in those two NFC championship games in Philly. Oh, yeah. Seattle didn't lose a playoff game they have been favored in the past couple of years. How about the Eagles....

 

An Eagles fan calling any other team a choker? Priceless. FACE.

 

Also, curious. Why do you think I'm fat?

[parrot 789]

Yup. That's the guy. I bet Cassel saw it, too. Sitting in a recliner somewhere.

 

Bwahahaha

Nice change of subject. Wtf does Cassel have to do with the price of Chunky Soup in China?

 

Newbie wants to talk about the Patriots even in his own thread about the Eagles. Now there's a shocker.

 

I guess it's easier to bring up the Patriots than to address the fact that the guy you're forwarding as one of the all-time great "clutch" Qbs just yesterday committed one of the all-time stupidest moves by any QB, ever, in clutch time of a playoff game.

 

Since we're more concerned with the Patriots than the thread topic; I wonder if Tom Brady might be sitting in a recliner somewhere too, polishing his three superbowl rings, coincidentally the same number of rings as McNabb had picks when the two teams met in the biggest game of McNabb's career.

[phillybear 366]

I can understand living in the area and hearing about them 24-7 and that grating on you,

 

The frustrating part is that Eagle fans are bandwagon fans. No local sports fans talk about them until the win a couple of playoff games. Just like NewbieJr

[jgcrawfish 232]

honestly, the difference in the game was manning's poor play under pressure. and trust me, i know it when i see it. his play reminded me of a Romo stinker.

 

You guys should heed this...a cowboys fan would definitely know a choker when he sees one!

[49ers_suck 0]

time for the eagles to lose another NFC champ. game!

[The Next Generation 10]

I think this is why guys like phillybear are hating on the Eagles today. The Eagles took it to the Giants yesterday? That would imply that they dominated that game statistically.

 

Total Yards- NYG 307 PHI 276

Passing Yards- NYG 169 PHI 217

Rushing Yards- NYG 138 PHI 59

First Downs- NYG 16 PHI 20

Time of Possession- NYG 30:15 PHI 29:45

 

Looks like a pretty evenly played game to me. The difference was a few plays in the game. INT by Manning that gave the Eagles the ball 1st and Goal. Poor play calling by the Giants in the 4th quarter and the biggest difference was that McNabb made big throws when he needed to and Eli didn't. Hardely a domination by either team.

 

Sorry, but stats alone are worthless. The Eagles adjusted and dominated the game in the 2nd half. You do realize that the Giants didn't score a TD, right? Sure the difference was a few plays in the game, but the Eagles made those few plays. What did the Giants do? Nada.

[phillybear 366]

Wouldn't you be miserable if you led the anti-Obama charge and ended up looking foolish, supported a team that ended up 4-12 and with teh fourth overall draft pick next year, and had to watch the Philadelphia Eagles rise from teh dead in week 17 to make this miraculous playoff run? All while realizing that he could have chosen to be a fan of his hometown team, but instead chose a joke of a franchise with a quarterback who's 4-5 lifetime in the playoffs.

 

Hasselbeck finally learned how to avoid his usal playoff chokefest....start choking during the regular season, instead.

 

Bwahahahaha. haha. hee hee

 

TAINT

 

I understand that you are living on food stamps and will be on welfare soon because no one would hire a wiseass like you, but if you want to talk about politics, go to the Geek Bored. So let's get to your SELF QWNAGE in this thread.

 

Has anyone tackled Joe Jurivicius yet, or is he still running? And then McNabb tossed that gaming ending INT vs Tampa Bay. Such a shame. *GAG*

[Eagles Green 34]

Also, curious. Why do you think I'm fat?

1. You don't have the balls to post a geek pic

2. Your posts smell like cheese

[The Next Generation 10]

The frustrating part is that Eagle fans are bandwagon fans. No local sports fans talk about them until the win a couple of playoff games. Just like NewbieJr

 

Puh...lease...if you go by the type of fans that call in to local sports radio, than you are basing your opinion on the wrong type of fan. Yeesh...those putzes are like sheep being led to slaughter (i.e. the McNabb draft fiasco).

[phillybear 366]

Did you see the play he made on 3rd and 20?, that was vintage McNabb.

 

I'll give him credit on that one. But the Giants whiffed on the sack. McNabb should have gone down. He did a nice job of staying alive.

 

Yes, the Eagles are mediocre at everything.

[Stewburtx8 67]

I think this is why guys like phillybear are hating on the Eagles today. The Eagles took it to the Giants yesterday? That would imply that they dominated that game statistically.

 

Total Yards- NYG 307 PHI 276

Passing Yards- NYG 169 PHI 217

Rushing Yards- NYG 138 PHI 59

First Downs- NYG 16 PHI 20

Time of Possession- NYG 30:15 PHI 29:45

 

Looks like a pretty evenly played game to me. The difference was a few plays in the game. INT by Manning that gave the Eagles the ball 1st and Goal. Poor play calling by the Giants in the 4th quarter and the biggest difference was that McNabb made big throws when he needed to and Eli didn't. Hardely a domination by either team.

 

 

No, that does not mean they dominated the game statistically. Obviously this was a very close game all day until late in the 4th quarter. But they took it to the Giants when they had to in the trenches. The Giants, the best running team in football, were stuffed on many short yardage situations by a "undersized" Eagles front 7. That was the difference in the game. The Giants only punted twice all day. Usually that is a very good offensive day. But the Eagles defense was "bend but don't break" all day, and made the plays when necessary. They forced FG attempt after FG attempt, stopped them on two 4th down attempts in the 4th quarter, and forced 3 turnovers. Obviously it wasn't Eli's best day, but some of that has to be attributed to Jim Johnson's varying defensive looks and schemes. I know this Eagles TEAM has been very jekyl and hyde this season, but that is more attributed to the offense, this defense has been VERY good all year. Top 3 in the NFL good. And now with the offense clicking, this team can be as good as anyone. Or they could revert to poor play calling and lose to a very hot Arizona team. I think if the Eagles play their best game, they will win, but I would never predict it with this team. I'm just going to enjoy the ride, and hope they continue to do what they have been doing.

[Durtee 0]

Sorry, but stats alone are worthless. The Eagles adjusted and dominated the game in the 2nd half. You do realize that the Giants didn't score a TD, right? Sure the difference was a few plays in the game, but the Eagles made those few plays. What did the Giants do? Nada.

 

Did you read my post? Because that is pretty much what I said. "McNabb made plays when he needed to" and "Eli didn't". Eagles fans are saying that their team dominated the Giants. Well that would imply that statistically they dominated the game. The Eagles did not dominate the game in the 2nd half. They played better and that is why they won, but nothing about the win was dominating. It's silliness like this that is causing people to hate on the Eagles.

[Eagles Green 34]

I'm tired of hearing all the undeserved praise for the Eagles. They are a very average team.

 

The "average" Eagles played 6 games this year vs. division winners.

 

They went 5-1.

 

Including 2 road wins vs the champs.

 

 

 

SCAPULA

[phillybear 366]

1. You don't have the balls to post a geek pic

2. Your posts smell like cheese

 

1. Why would somebody post a picture of themselves on a bored with 99% of the registered users male? If I had a family that was alive, why would I subject them to the same? Also, I have no use for a cell phone or a camera of any type, so I haven't taken a photo since the last time I renewed my driver's licence. If you want to think of me as fat, go ahead. No worries. I will admit that I am tall at 6'3". So if I'm tall and fat, just point me in the direction of the Mellon store.

 

2. I like cheese.

[phillybear 366]

The "average" Eagles played 6 games this year vs. division winners.

 

They went 5-1.

 

Including 2 road wins vs the champs.

SCAPULA

 

Therefore, the division winners comprise all 4 of the teams remaining in the playoffs at this point. Nope. Look, the Eagles played in a bad division and rolled up some unimpressive wins against less than mediocre teams this year.

 

The NFL had no dominant team entering the playoffs, and now parity has pushed the Eagles into a great spot. Congrats.

[NewbieJr 541]

Nice change of subject. Wtf does Cassel have to do with the price of Chunky Soup in China?

About as much as McNabb picking up a phone, as a joke, in an already-decided game has to do with his choking.

 

HTH

[jgcrawfish 232]

2. I like cheese.

 

To go with all that whine, er, wine???

 

[NewbieJr 541]

Therefore, the division winners comprise all 4 of the teams remaining in the playoffs at this point. Nope. Look, the Eagles played in a bad division and rolled up some unimpressive wins against less than mediocre teams this year.

 

The NFL had no dominant team entering the playoffs, and now parity has pushed the Eagles into a great spot. Congrats.

The Eagles play in a bad division. That's a good one. How did Seattle fare against that division this year?

 

I'll hang up and listen.

[Eagles Green 34]

1. Why would somebody post a picture of themselves on a bored with 99% of the registered users male? If I had a family that was alive, why would I subject them to the same? Also, I have no use for a cell phone or a camera of any type, so I haven't taken a photo since the last time I renewed my driver's licence. If you want to think of me as fat, go ahead. No worries. I will admit that I am tall at 6'3". So if I'm tall and fat, just point me in the direction of the Mellon store.

 

2. I like cheese.

So you've admitted being 6'3"

You also mention having a job.

Sometimes you show creativity and wit.

 

So you are either:

1. Fat

2. Disfigured

3. Ghey

4. All of the above

[jgcrawfish 232]

2. I like cheese.

 

To go with all that whine, er, wine???

 

 

if the average height of the american male is 5' 10", how come EVERYBODY on this board is 6' 3" ???

 

But online I'm out in hollywood, I'm 6'5" and I look damned good.  I drive a maseratti am a blackbelt in karate and a I love a good glass of whine (er, wine).  :rolleyes:

[parrot 789]

About as much as McNabb picking up a phone, as a joke, in an already-decided game has to do with his choking.

 

HTH

 

Yeah, twelve point NFL games with three minutes remaining are completely decided. And yeah, the decisions a QB makes in clutch time are completely irrelevant to how good a clutch QB he is.

 

It doesn't matter that it was a joke, it was ASTOUNDINGLY stupid given the situation.

[phillybear 366]

Puh...lease...if you go by the type of fans that call in to local sports radio, than you are basing your opinion on the wrong type of fan. Yeesh...those putzes are like sheep being led to slaughter (i.e. the McNabb draft fiasco).

 

The same 12 people call sports radio shows.

 

Also, I think the fans were great on draft day. They did the right thing, booing management, no matter how the pick turned out. The problem is that faggity McNabb has never gotten over it. He constants whines about it in interviews, as recently as last year. The fans booed me. No, you lunkhead, they were booing management. Dammit, McNabb has a head full of pudding. What a mook.

[redtodd 7]

Nice! If McNabb can win his next 14 playoff wins in a row, he can have the same winning percentage as Brady.

[Dan 66]

if the average height of the american male is 5' 10", how come EVERYBODY on this board is 6' 3" ???

 

I'm 5' 7 1/2". I drag it down a little.

[phillybear 366]

So you've admitted being 6'3"

You also mention having a job.

Sometimes you show creativity and wit.

 

So you are either:

1. Fat

2. Disfigured

3. Ghey

4. All of the above

 

My name is William and I like to wear finger nail polish.

[phillybear 366]

To go with all that whine, er, wine???

 

 

if the average height of the american male is 5' 10", how come EVERYBODY on this board is 6' 3" ???

 

But online I'm out in hollywood, I'm 6'5" and I look damned good.  I drive a maseratti am a blackbelt in karate and a I love a good glass of whine (er, wine).  :rolleyes:

 

I was going for a Thornton Mellon joke....sigh...nevermind.

[NewbieJr 541]

So you've admitted being 6'3"

You also mention having a job.

Sometimes you show creativity and wit.

 

So you are either:

1. Fat

2. Disfigured

3. Ghey

4. All of the above

phillybear can't post a picture because he likes to come off as a psychopathic headcase. He's either the most effeminate looking little pussie, or he's so grotesque looking that no one would converse with him anymore.

 

Since 90% of our members gladly post pictures, you just know he has something to hide.

[FlaHawker 24]

The same 12 people call sports radio shows.

 

Also, I think the fans were great on draft day. They did the right thing, booing management, no matter how the pick turned out. The problem is that faggity McNabb has never gotten over it. He constants whines about it in interviews, as recently as last year. The fans booed me. No, you lunkhead, they were booing management. Dammit, McNabb has a head full of pudding. What a mook.

Troy Aikman said it best yesterday after Mr. Glass picked up the phone trying to be funny, "I don't know what goes through that guy's head sometimes..."

[phillybear 366]

Well, that's the end of my lunch break. The grapefruit was a bit overripe, but thanks for asking.

 

I have to go back to work, but I'm sure NewbieJr will be around to continue the discussion. Because he has no job.

[Rybo5 0]

McNabb is arguably the best qb in eagles history, but I don't think he's really made much of a reputation for being "clutch". He's come up big in some moments, but there's been some unpleasantness as well.

[plasma george 62]

Therefore, the division winners comprise all 4 of the teams remaining in the playoffs at this point. Nope. Look, the Eagles played in a bad division and rolled up some unimpressive wins against less than mediocre teams this year.

 

The NFL had no dominant team entering the playoffs, and now parity has pushed the Eagles into a great spot. Congrats.

Parity pushed Carolina, Titans, Giants, Atlanta, Minnesota to all those meaningless, useless Wins during the season.....where are these "above average teams" ? If the Eagles are average (like you say), how do we refer to the teams that didn't make the playoffs ? There are 26 teams watching the Final Four, 4 out of 26.

 

In short, you're either an idiot, not understanding the definition of "average", or you're incredibly biased/twisted in your comments......either way, do us a favor and stop posting as we're all getting dumber.