2012 Consensus Rankings Voting Thread: WIDE RECEIVERS

[Mike FF Today 608]

The Geek Consensus Rankings are back for 2012. worm has graciously offered his services to gather up the results.

 

• Please use this thread to vote for your Top 30 WRs for the 2012 season.
  
• Redraft League, Standard Performance / FF Today scoring should be used to rank the players - NO PPR!
  
• Voting will last until midnight PM PST on Thursda, 8/16
  
• Once the voting is over, the results will be documented then tabulated.
  
• Traditional polling measures will be used to determine the results
  

Thanks in advance for your participation! We hope this proves to be a helpful resource in establishing a baseline for your upcoming drafts.

[Mike FF Today 608]

1. Calvin Johnson, DET

2. Roddy White, ATL

3. Victor Cruz, NYG

4. Percy Harvin, MIN

5. Marques Colston, NO

6. Julio Jones, ATL

7. Wes Welker, NE

8. Greg Jennings, GB

9. Mike Wallace, PIT

10. Andre Johnson, HOU

11. Hakeem Nicks NYG

12. Larry Fitzgerald, ARI

13. A.J. Green, CIN

14. Jordy Nelson, GB

15. Steve Smith, CAR

16. Dez Bryant, DAL

17. Jeremy Maclin, PHI

18. Antonio Brown, PIT

19. Brandon Marshall, CHI

20. Miles Austin, DAL

21. Steve Johnson, BUF

22. Vincent Jackson, TB

23. Dwayne Bowe, KC

24. Eric Decker, DEN

25. Robert Meachem, SD

26. Torrey Smith, BAL

27. Demaryius Thomas, DEN

28. Darrius Heyward-Bey, OAK

29. Santonio Holmes, NYJ

30. Pierre Garcon, WAS

[worm 34]

Quick request: if you guys edit your list during the voting period, it would be a BIG help if you noted the date of the edit at the bottom of your post. That way I can get the final rankings out a lot quicker. Thanks!

 

1. Calvin Johnson

2. Larry Fitzgerald

3. AJ Green

4. Greg Jennings

5. Victor Cruz

6. Andre Johnson

7. Roddy White

8. Marques Colston

9. Steve Smith (CAR)

10. Hakeem Nicks

11. Brandon Marshall

12. Julio Jones

13. Percy Harvin

14. Miles Austin

15. Mike Wallace

16. Jordy Nelson

17. Dez Bryant

18. Reggie Wayne

19. Wes Welker

20. Vincent Jackson

21. DeSean Jackson

22. Demaryius Thomas

23. Dwayne Bowe

24. Steve Johnson

25. Jeremy Maclin

26. Antonio Brown

27. Robert Meachem

28. Torrey Smith

29. Brandon Lloyd

30. Pierre Garcon

Edited August 17, 2012 by worm

[carmo911 2]

1. C. Johnson - DET

2. J. Jones - ATL

3. V. Cruz - NYG

4. W. Welker - NE

5. R. White - ATL

6. G. Jennings - GB

7. P. Harvin - MIN

8. A.J. Green - CIN

9. L. Fitzgerald - ARI

10. H. Nicks - NYG

11. M. Wallace - PIT

12. B. Marshall - CHI

13. A. Johnson - HOU

14. D. Bryant - DAL

15. J. Nelson - GB

16. A. Brown - PIT

17. J. Maclin - PHI

18. M. Colston - NO

19. S. Johnson - BUF

20. D. Bowe - KC

21. B. Lloyd - NE

22. V. Jackson - TB

23. D. Moore - OAK

24. E. Decker - TEN

25. D. Thomas - DEN

26. R. Wayne - IND

27. T. Young - DET

28. M. Austin - DAL

29. R. Meachem - SD

30. D. Heyward-Bey - Oak

[Raider 84 29]

1. C. Johnson

2. J. Jones

3. V. Cruz

4. H. Nicks

5. Marshall

6. AJ Green

7. A. Johnson

8. R. White

9. Fitzgerald

10. J. Nelson

11. Welker

12. Jennings

13. Harvin

14. Wallace

15. Bryant

16. Maclin

17. Colston

18. A. Brown

19. D. Thomas

20. Decker

21. Austin

22. Bowe

23. S. Johnson

24. Lloyd

25. D. Jackson

26. V. Jackson

27. D. Moore

28. T. Smith

29. Garcon

30. T. Young

[ralphster 274]

1. Johnson - DET

2. White - ATL

3. Green - CIN

4. Johnson - HOU

5. Jones - ATL

6. Welker - NE

7. Nicks - NYG

8. Fitzgerald - ARI

9. Marshall - CHI

10. Jennings - GB

11. Cruz - NYG

12. Harvin - MIN

13. Colston - NO

14. Brown - PIT

15. Decker - DEN

16. Smith - CAR

17. Maclin - PHI

18. Austin - DAL

19. Nelson - GB

20. Thomas - DEN

21. Johnson - BUF

22. Lloyd - NE

23. T Smith - BAL

24. Bryant - DAL

25. Wayne - IND

26. Jackson - TB

27. DHB - OAK

28. Bowe/Baldwin - KC

29. Garcon - WAS

30. Moss - SF

[vegassandwich227 0]

1. Megatron

2. J Nelson

3. Fitz

4. AJ

5. Cruz

6. R White

7. Julio

8. Jennings

9. S Smith

10. AJ Green

11. Dez

12. Nicks

13. Welker

14. Marshall

15. Harvin

16. Stevie J

17. Colston

18. D Jax

19. Wallace

20. Bowe

21. Austin

22. Maclin

23. A Brown

24. S Holmes

25. Torrey S

26. Wayne

27. N Wash

28. Garcon

29. Dem Thomas

30. V Jax

[MicktheGreat 1]

1. Calvin Johnson, DET

2. A.J. Green, CIN

3. Julio Jones, ATL

4. Andre Johnson, HOU

5. Larry Fitzgerald, ARI

6. Victor Cruz, NYG

7. Mike Wallace, PIT

8. Greg Jennings, GB

9. Roddy White, ATL

10. Brandon Lloyd, NE

11. Brandon Marshall, CHI

12. Jordy Nelson, GB

13. Dez Bryant, DAL

14. Hakeem Nicks, NYG

15. Stevie Johnson, BUF

16. Jeremy Maclin, PHI

17. Wes Welker, NE

18. Kenny Britt, TEN

19. Steve Smith, CAR

20. Miles Austin, DAL

21. Eric Decker, DEN

22. DeSean Jackson, PHI

23. Dwayne Bowe, KC

24. Marques Colston, NO

25. Vincent Jackson, TB

26. Percy Harvin, MIN

27. Justin Blackmon, JAX

28. Antonio Brown, PIT

29. Demaryius Thomas, DEN

30. Darrius Heyward-Bey, OAK

[LSUtiger 9]

1. Calvin Johnson, DET

2. Roddy White, ATL

3. Victor Cruz, NYG

4. Percy Harvin, MIN

5. Marques Colston, NO

6. Julio Jones, ATL

7. Wes Welker, NE

8. Greg Jennings, GB

9. Mike Wallace, PIT

10. Andre Johnson, HOU

11. Hakeem Nicks NYG

12. Larry Fitzgerald, ARI

13. A.J. Green, CIN

14. Jordy Nelson, GB

15. Steve Smith, CAR

16. Dez Bryant, DAL

17. Jeremy Maclin, PHI

18. Antonio Brown, PIT

19. Brandon Marshall, CHI

20. Miles Austin, DAL

21. Steve Johnson, BUF

22. Vincent Jackson, TB

23. Dwayne Bowe, KC

24. Eric Decker, DEN

25. Robert Meachem, SD

26. Torrey Smith, BAL

27. Demaryius Thomas, DEN

28. Darrius Heyward-Bey, OAK

29. Santonio Holmes, NYJ

30. Pierre Garcon, WAS

 

No Brandon Lloyd in your top 30 WRs? Hmm.

[Phurfur 70]

1 Johnson, Calvin

2 Fitzgerald, Larry

3 Jones, Julio

4 Marshall, Brandon

5 Johnson, Andre

6 Cruz, Victor

7 Welker, Wes

8 White, Roddy

9 Green, A.J.

10 Nelson, Jordy

11 Jennings, Greg

12 Wallace, Mike

13 Smith, Steve

14 Nicks, Hakeem

15 Bryant, Dez

16 Harvin, Percy

17 Colston, Marques

18 Johnson, Steve

19 Austin, Miles

20 Jackson, DeSean

21 Jackson, Vincent

22 Thomas, Demaryius

23 Bowe, Dwayne

24 Brown, Antonio

25 Lloyd, Brandon

27 Garcon, Pierre

26 Decker, Eric

28 Boldin, Anquan

29 Meachem, Robert

30 Wayne, Reggie

[Mike FF Today 608]

No Brandon Lloyd in your top 30 WRs? Hmm.

 

He's #31.

[UNCDave 0]

1 Johnson, Calvin

2 White, Roddy

3 Jennings, Greg

4 Welker, Wes

5 Johnson, Andre

6 Cruz, Victor

7 Fitzgerald, Larry

8 Harvin, Percy

9 Smith, Steve (CAR)

10 Marshall, Brandon

11 Jones, Julio

12 Brown, Antonio

13 Green, A.J.

14 Nicks, Hakeem

15 Bryant, Dez

16 Austin, Miles

17 Colston, Marques

18 Johnson, Steve

19 Wallace, Mike

20 Nelson, Jordy

21 Decker, Eric

22 Thomas, Demaryius

23 Bowe, Dwayne

24 Maclin, Jeremy

25 Garcon, Pierre

26 Smith, Torrey

27 Jackson, Vincent

28 Lloyd, Brandon

29 Meachem, Robert

30 Wayne, Reggie

[giraldi02 470]

1. Megatron

2. Roddy White

3. Fitzgerald

4. Julio Jones

5. Nicks

6. Harvin

7. AJ Green

8. Welker

9. Brandon Marshall

10. Andre Johnson

11. Jordy Nelson

12. Cruz

13. Steve Smith (CAR)

14. Dez Bryant

15. Maclin

16. Stevie Johnson

17. Jennings (That concussion is scaring me A LOT)

18. Colston

19. Decker

20. Desean Jackson

21. Dwayne Bowe

22. Pierre Garcon

23. Torrey Smith

24. Antonio Brown

25. Miles Austin

26. Brandon Lloyd

27. Vincent Jackson

28. Demaryious Thomas

29. Reggie Wayne

30. Titus Young

[We Tigers 71]

The Wallace rankings interest me. I'm just leaving him off altogether for now, but fun to see people's implied belief in how his contract situation will shake out.

 

1. Calvin Johnson

2. Larry Fitzgerald

3. Brandon Marshall

4. Greg Jennings

5. Roddy White

6. Julio Jones

7. AJ Green

8. Andre Johnson

9. Percy Harvin

10. Victor Cruz

11. Wes Welker

12. Hakeem Nicks

13. Marques Colston

14. Steve Smith

15. Dez Bryant

16. Jeremy Maclin

17. Antonio Brown

18. Jordy Nelson

19. Miles Austin

20. Brandon Lloyd

21. Stevie Johnson

22. Eric Decker

23. Demaryius Thomas

24. Vincent Jackson

25. Dwayne Bowe

26. DeSean Jackson

27. Torrey Smith

28. Darius Heyward-Bey

29. Nate Washington

30. Titus Young

[Ditka vs. ______ 0]

1 Calvin Johnson

2 Larry Fitzgerald

3 Julio Jones

4 Greg Jennings

5 Andre Johnson

6 Roddy White

7 Victor Cruz

8 Wes Welker

9 Hakeem Nicks

10 Percy Harvin

11 Marques Colston

12 Jordy Nelson

13 Brandon Marshall

14 Dez Bryant

15 Steve Smith (CAR)

16 Miles Austin

17 Mike Wallace

18 Jeremy Maclin

19 Eric Decker

20 A.J. Green

21 Vincent Jackson

22 Dwayne Bowe

23 Demaryius Thomas

24 Steve Johnson

25 Pierre Garcon

26 Torrey Smith

27 Brandon Lloyd

28 DeSean Jackson

29 Antonio Brown

30 Robert Meachem

[mobb_deep 917]

1) Calvin Johnson

2) Julio Jones

3) Larry Fitzgerald

4) Greg Jennings

5) Wes Welker

6) Andre Johnson

7) Brandon Marshall

8) Roddy White

9) A.J. Green

10) Victor Cruz

11) Jordy Nelson

12) Hakeem Nicks

13) Dez Bryant

14) Steve Smith

15) Marques Colston

16) Percy Harvin

17) Brandon Lloyd

18) Demaryius Thomas

19) Mike Wallace

20) Miles Austin

21) Jeremy Maclin

22) Antonio Brown

23) Eric Decker

24) DeSean Jackson

25) Vincent Jackson

26) Dwayne Bowe

27) Stevie Johnson

28) Pierre Garcon

29) Torrey Smith

30) Reggie Wayne

[freighttrain 0]

1. Calvin Johnson

2. Julio Jones

3. Victor Cruz

4. Wes Welker

5. Larry Fitzgerald

6. Roddy White

7. Greg Jennings

8. Jordy Nelson

9. A.J. Green

10. Andre Johnson

11. Steve Smith

12. Hakeem Nicks

13. Percy Harvin

14. Brandon Lloyd

15. Brandon Marshall

16. Marques Colston

17. Demaryious Thomas

18. Dez Bryant

19. Miles Austin

20. Antonio Brown

21. Eric Decker

22. Reggie Wayne

23. Jeremy Maclin

24. DeSean Jackson

25. Steve Johnson

26. Mike Wallace

27. Dwayne Bowe

28. Kendall Wright

29. Pierre Garcon

30. Vincent Brown

[robb 71]

1 Johnson,Det

2 Johnson,A

3 Fitzgerald,Ariz

4 Green, Cin

5 Welker,NE

6 Jones, Atl

7 Jennings,GB

8 Nicks,Giants

9 White, Atl

10 Marshall, Chi

11 Wallace,Pit

12 Colston

13 Maclin, Phil

14 Thomas, Denver

15 Bryant, Dallas

16 Bowe,KC

17 Johnson, Buf

18 Harvin, Minn

19 Austin

20 Cruz

21 Nelson, GB

22 Jackson,TB

23 Lloyd, NE

24 Smith,S,Car

25 Smith, Balt

26 Moore,D.,Oak

27 Jackson,Phil

28 Britt, Ten

29 Brown, Pit

30 Decker, Denver

[Bishop82 61]

1. Larry Fitzgerald, ARI

2. Calvin Johnson, DET

3. Roddy White, ATL

4. Victor Cruz, NYG

5. Greg Jennings, GB

6. Marques Colston, NO

7. Julio Jones, ATL

8. Wes Welker, NE

9. Brandon Marshall, CHI

10. Andre Johnson, HOU

11. Hakeem Nicks NYG

12. Jordy Nelson, GB

13. A.J. Green, CIN

14. Percy Harvin, MIN

15. Steve Smith, CAR

16. Jeremy Maclin, PHI

17. Steve Johnson, BUF

18. Miles Austin, DAL

19. Antonio Brown, PIT

20. Eric Decker, DEN

21. Demaryius Thomas, DEN

22. Dwayne Bowe, KC

23. Brandon Lloyd, NE

24. Mike Wallace, PIT

25. Kenny Britt, TEN

26. Vincent Jackson, TB

27. Nate Washington, TEN

28. Reggie Wayne, IND

29. Vincent Brown, SD

30. Dez Bryant, DAL

[dain11279 928]

1 Johnson,Det

2 Johnson,A

3 Fitzgerald,Ariz

4 Green, Cin

5 Welker,NE

6 Jones, Atl

7 Jennings,GB

8 Nicks,Giants

9 White, Atl

10 Marshall, Chi

11 Wallace,Pit

12 Colston

13 Maclin, Phil

14 Thomas, Denver

15 Bryant, Dallas

16 Bowe,KC

17 Johnson, Buf

18 Harvin, Minn

19 Austin

20 Cruz

21 Nelson, GB

22 Jackson,TB

23 Lloyd, NE

24 Smith,S,Car

25 Smith, Balt

26 Moore,D.,Oak

27 Jackson,Phil

28 Britt, Ten

29 Brown, Pit

30 Decker, Denver

 

I'd put him higher if he lands in a triangle offense

[montana 89]

1. megatron

2. white

3. colston

4. julio

5. cruz

6. jennings

7. nicks

8. welker

9. fitz

10. a johnson

11. harvin

12. bryant

13. lloyd

14. marshall

15. nelson

16. wallace

17. green

18. austin

19. s smith

20. a brown

21. s johnson

22. maclin

23. bowe

24. decker

25. garcon

26. d thomas

27. d jackson

28. t young

29. wayne

30. d moore

[David PatteRn 0]

1. Calvin Johnson, DET
   
2. Larry Fitzgerald, ARI
   
3. Greg Jennings, GB
   
4. Andre Johnson, HOU
   
5. Julio Jones, ATL
   
6. Victor Cruz, NYG
   
7. Brandon Marshall, CHI
   
8. Wes Welker, NE
   
9. Roddy White, ATL
   
10. Jordy Nelson, GB
    
11. Hakeem Nicks, NYG
    
12. A.J. Green, CIN
    
13. Steve Smith, CAR
    
14. Dez Bryant, DAL
    
15. Mike Wallace, PIT
    
16. Percy Harvin, MIN
    
17. Brandon Lloyd, NE
    
18. Marques Colston, NO
    
19. Miles Austin, DAL
    
20. Demaryius Thomas, DEN
    
21. Dwayne Bowe, KC
    
22. Jeremy Maclin, PHI
    
23. Vincent Jackson, TB
    
24. Steve Johnson, BUF
    
25. Eric Decker, DEN
    
26. Antonio Brown, PIT
    
27. DeSean Jackson, PHI
    
28. Kenny Britt, TEN
    
29. Torrey Smith, BAL
    
30. Lance Moore, NO
    

[worm 34]

Voting is closed.