I was Right !!! I was Wrong ...

[GobbleDog 1,020]

I was right that Ashton Jeanty was ridiculously over-rated on that garbage team. 

I was wrong believing Tank Bigsby would take over the Jags backfield and officially become the Sleeper of the Year. 

........................................................

I was right that Jahmyr Gibbs was worthy of the #1 overall pick due to health, a billion receptions, and a juggernaut team. 

I was wrong thinking Puka Nacua wasn't worth an early pick, because Matt Stafford can't stay healthy.

....................................................

I was right that James Cook is a stud and the prior year's limited snap count was due to the Bills blowing everyone out.

I was wrong thinking Liam Coen could turn Trevor Lawrence into Mayfield-Lite and Brian Thomas Jr would have a tremendous season. 

...............................................
 

How about yall? 

[weepaws 3,471]

St Brown, never have I had him on my team, darn glad I targeted him early, wrong on JSN.  

J Cook, he was a big target of mind during mock drafts, glad have him, wrong on Taylor, wish I would have taken him over Barkley.  

Right on taking my Qbs and Tes late, 

 

[GobbleDog 1,020]

44 minutes ago, weepaws said:

wrong on Taylor

Same. Lots of logical reasons to avoid.... total o-line shake-up, min receptions, Daniel Jones at Qb.... 2nd rd pick seemed way too expensive at the time. 

[gcmmidwest 155]

4 hours ago, weepaws said:

St Brown, never have I had him on my team, darn glad I targeted him early, wrong on JSN.  

J Cook, he was a big target of mind during mock drafts, glad have him, wrong on Taylor, wish I would have taken him over Barkley.  

Right on taking my Qbs and Tes late, 

 

Taking QBs & te double digit rounds is why you didn't make the playoffs 

[weepaws 3,471]

Wrong about, T Etienne, didn’t really pay him much attention at the draft.  

Right about Ja Williams, I thought his ADP was incredible.  Cowboys 

Wrong about DK Metcalf, I didn’t draft him, but I expected more from him   

Right about G Pickens, I didn’t think he would be this good, but he’s been, his avg per game non ppr, is ahead of Lamb   

 

[JagFan 199]

I was right about Trevor Lawrence, currently sitting at QB6 in fantasy points and #4 in odds to win MVP….Oh, and the Jags are playing very good football going into the playoffs.  Has 2 more games to improve on both.

I was wrong about Justin Fields.  Going to the Jets should’ve been my first clue…

[Bills04 66]

Right =

Goes against Weepaws, but - ARI TE McBride at 3.03

Egbuka at 8.11

Dak Prescott at 11.02

W-Rob at 15.02

 

WRONG =

Saquon at 1.02

Bo Nix at 5.02

Tuten at 9.02

[josh wiley 77]

Thinking jeudy could follow up on last years performance (albeit a lot in one game). Way the hell off on that one

[GobbleDog 1,020]

4 hours ago, JagFan said:

I was right about Trevor Lawrence, currently sitting at QB6 in fantasy points

You were wrong.  Wks 1-14 Lawrence was Qb 15 and his Qb rating ranked 29th in the league.   

Two fluke weeks doesn't change the fact that Lawrence is an over-paid bum who can't get beyond his first read. 

[GobbleDog 1,020]

3 hours ago, Bills04 said:

Tuten at 9.02

If I'd known I was going to be wrong about Tank, I would've assumed Tuten did way better than expected.

Etienne's metrics were beyond putrid last year and didn't seem like he'd amount to anything this season - or ever again.  So much for metrics.  

[rotisserieking 83]

I was right about the Maye hype and took him in the 10th.

I was right that Jayden Daniels would be a bust (injury or not).

I was wrong to think Evans could return to glory when I took him at 4.02.

I was dead wrong to take Kittle over James Cook at 3.09. Guy behind me went Cook 3.10 and JSN 4.01. OUCH.

[JagFan 199]

On 12/27/2025 at 2:56 PM, GobbleDog said:

You were wrong.  Wks 1-14 Lawrence was Qb 15 and his Qb rating ranked 29th in the league.   

Two fluke weeks doesn't change the fact that Lawrence is an over-paid bum who can't get beyond his first read. 

He’s up to QB 5.  You misspelled trend.

[WhiteWonder 3,035]

It was not a great draft year for me and my success in leagues was almost entirely attributed to properly working waivers, free agency and trades. 

I was right that Seattle was the DST to pick in the last round of drafts. I was right that Fairbairn was the kicker to pick last. I was right that Barkley should not go ahead of Robinson or Gibbs and that Taylor would be a nice value. Right on Henderson in dynasty. ... and right that Rashee Rice would be a stud after his suspension if you could tread water until then. I guess also right about Drake London prior to the injury. 

Totally wrong on Kamara as a PPR value in round 4. Wrong about Calvin Ridley. Wrong about Mike Evans although that was more injury related. Very wrong about Justin Fields on the Jets. The Jets organization is probably more to blame there than Fields as they never used him correctly prior to his benching. 

[RareN64Dream 26]

I thought Tua Tagovailoa would have a better season overall. That could mostly be attributed to Tyreek Hill getting that serious injury and their run game was pretty strong, it seemed. I also was another person who thought Justin Fields would do better.

Kyler Murray, Omarion Hampton, Bucky Irving, Garrett Wilson, Travis Hunter and Tucker Kraft injuries were upsetting.

I thought Jordan Addison would do better overall.

I was right about Jonathan Taylor, Josh Jacobs and Javonte Williams. I was undefeated in that league until Week 8 or 9 rolled around. Another league I was doing well overall and got #1 seed; I was right about Matthew Stafford and pretty correct about some other draft picks.

[weepaws 3,471]

Tua lack of production is without question due to Hill. 

[gcmmidwest 155]

20 hours ago, weepaws said:

Tua lack of production is without question due to Hill. 

Learn from your mistakes don't wait on a QB 

[RareN64Dream 26]

6 hours ago, gcmmidwest said:

Learn from your mistakes don't wait on a QB 

In the league I needed Tua the most to help me; I had Sam Darnold and Dak Prescott to pick up the slack. It is a 2 QB start. I went WR heavy. My 4 best WR were Ja'Marr Chase, Amon Ra-St. Brown, Justin Jefferson and Chris Olave. My RB were pretty bad initially and Najee Harris got a season ending injury, eventually.

[gcmmidwest 155]

41 minutes ago, RareN64Dream said:

In the league I needed Tua the most to help me; I had Sam Darnold and Dak Prescott to pick up the slack. It is a 2 QB start. I went WR heavy. My 4 best WR were Ja'Marr Chase, Amon Ra-St. Brown, Justin Jefferson and Chris Olave. My RB were pretty bad initially and Najee Harris got a season ending injury, eventually.

How many teams? 

[weepaws 3,471]

3 hours ago, gcmmidwest said:

How many teams? 

Here comes his judgement of your league/team beware of this fool.

[JagFan 199]

9 hours ago, gcmmidwest said:

How many teams? 

Oh, this one’s easy and I can answer it even though I’m not in this league.  There were enough teams to have a FF league just like all the leagues you’re in.  That’s how many, and you’re welcome!

[gcmmidwest 155]

7 hours ago, weepaws said:

Here comes his judgement of your league/team beware of this fool.

Matthew 5:22: Jesus warned that calling someone a "fool" (Greek: mōre) puts you in danger of hell, emphasizing that such labeling carries severe spiritual weight

[Maximum Overkill 2,699]

I tried trading for JSN in a dynasty league pre-season but the other team's owner wanted 2 first round picks. 

Like an idiot I was only willing to give up a 2025 1st round pick and a 2026 2nd round pick. 

I'm going to regret that one for years. 

Pre-season I thought that Justin Fields was going to be a steal. I couldn't of been more wrong, he's rotting on my bench. 

 

 

[Phil Simms 11 134]

Cook and Javonte

BTJ and McLaurin 

[RareN64Dream 26]

On 1/1/2026 at 8:31 PM, gcmmidwest said:

How many teams? 

10 team league. I tried to rely at RB position with Tony Pollard and the Tuten rookie on Jaguars, also Najee Harris. Because I spent so much on my WRs, I picked up Travis Hunter and Brandon Aiyuk on accident; same with Olave somewhat for $6. I wanted a 4th one for $1; instead of 6 WR, but it didn't work out. I was rushing too much and didn't bring my laptop, I think.

I can't remember when Harris got hurt. But, I eventually picked up Henderson rookie from Patriots in November and I think, before that I picked up Rico Dowdle, Zach Charbonnet and Isiah Pacheco. Pacheco didn't really do as well as I had hoped and same with Pollard, Tuten. I dropped Tuten around when Harris got hurt. I also picked up Woody Marks, Kimani Vidal. Dropped Charbonnet for Vidal.

I ended up getting 14-15 record, 5th place, averaged 117 points a game. We play 2 matchups weekly. I ended the season with 5 losses in a row. Lost in the 1st round of playoffs 170.30 to 144.05.

Burrow getting hurt affected Chase stats a bit overall, Jefferson did kind of bad stats wise in a few games towards end of the season, St. Brown was a bit banged up from that one injury when the lineman fell on his leg.

Dowdle started getting less carries when Hubbard got healthy for Panthers.

[gcmmidwest 155]

On 1/3/2026 at 11:07 AM, RareN64Dream said:

10 team league. I tried to rely at RB position with Tony Pollard and the Tuten rookie on Jaguars, also Najee Harris. Because I spent so much on my WRs, I picked up Travis Hunter and Brandon Aiyuk on accident; same with Olave somewhat for $6. I wanted a 4th one for $1; instead of 6 WR, but it didn't work out. I was rushing too much and didn't bring my laptop, I think.

I can't remember when Harris got hurt. But, I eventually picked up Henderson rookie from Patriots in November and I think, before that I picked up Rico Dowdle, Zach Charbonnet and Isiah Pacheco. Pacheco didn't really do as well as I had hoped and same with Pollard, Tuten. I dropped Tuten around when Harris got hurt. I also picked up Woody Marks, Kimani Vidal. Dropped Charbonnet for Vidal.

I ended up getting 14-15 record, 5th place, averaged 117 points a game. We play 2 matchups weekly. I ended the season with 5 losses in a row. Lost in the 1st round of playoffs 170.30 to 144.05.

Burrow getting hurt affected Chase stats a bit overall, Jefferson did kind of bad stats wise in a few games towards end of the season, St. Brown was a bit banged up from that one injury when the lineman fell on his leg.

Dowdle started getting less carries when Hubbard got healthy for Panthers.

Cookie crumbled hard for you ... The 12 teamers Leagues qb's are scarce 

[RareN64Dream 26]

On 1/4/2026 at 12:49 PM, gcmmidwest said:

Cookie crumbled hard for you ... The 12 teamers Leagues qb's are scarce 

Yeah, it is a 10 team league. 2 QB start, my QBs were Dak Prescott, Sam Darnold and Tua Tagovailoa.

[Flipper 73]

Just to put it into the memory hole ... 16-team redraft league.  I go zero-RB and drafted Nix/Maye at QB, McBride and Adams at the receiving spots, the Patriots 'D' and Charbonnet at RB.

The biggest mistake was taking BTJ over Nacua or St. Brown in round 1.

The adage that you cannot win your league in the first round but you certainly can lose it in the first round proved (financially) true.

I avoided St. Brown because their OL was weaker and he was coming off of a knee injury.  Nacua for a similar reason.