That was funny - I didn't know about him either until the second half of his breakout season. Even though he was lights out, there weren't many blurbs written about him. Then I finally read one and had a vague memory that a couple seasons earlier, in spring training, in an Os-Pirates game there was a matchup of Evan Phillips vs. Phillip Evans. So I raced to Baseball Reference, confirmed it was the same guy, and grabbed him. He immediately became my third best player according to the Yahoo rankings at the time.
But the next season was the real quandary - was he still under your and Burt's radar? Did I "out" him by picking him up the previous season? I decided not to risk it, so I think I drafted him in the second round (I didn't have many better options that year). Of course then the jig was completely up.