RLLD 4,230 Posted April 30, 2009 I know we will pin some ranking/voting threads in the coming months, but I am so FLIPPING bored..... Post your top 20 RB's in this thread, I will accumulate the rankings into one overall list. Here are mine. Remember, the purpose is to use everyone's collective thoughts to arrive at a better list, through insightful discussion. Keep the flames down. 1 - Adrian Peterson - Min 2 - Matt Forte - Chi 3 - Michael Turner - Atl 4 - Bryan Westbrook - Phi 5 - Ladanian Tomlinson - SD 6 - Steven Jackson - Stl 7 - Chris Johnson - Ten 8 - Clinton Portis - Was 9 - Marion Barber - Dal 10 - Maurice Jones-Drew - Jax 11 - DeAngelo Williams - Car 12 - Steve Slaton - Hou 13 - Brandon Jacobs - NYG 14 - Ryan Grant - Gb 15 - Willie Parker - Pit 16 - Kevin Smith - Det 17 - Joseph Addai - ind 18 - Frank Gore - SF 19 - Ronnie Brown - Mia 20 - Thomas Jones NYJ Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
dschddny 0 Posted April 30, 2009 From your list I'm surprised you have MJD, DeAngelo, and Gore so low. What's your reasoning on those? Seems that practically everyone on this board loves MJD in the top 3. Here are my top 20: A. Peterson M. Turner Jones-Drew DeAngelo Williams Westbrook M. Barber Matt Forte S. Jackson Portis Tomlinson Chris Johnson Gore Jacobs R. Brown Slaton Lynch R. Grant L. Johnson W. Parker Pierre Thomas Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gram 0 Posted April 30, 2009 i agree mjd should be higher than 10...but i still am not believing he is a top 3. im having a hard time keeping thomas jones in the top 20 w/his holdout and shonn green being drafted. big question is after lynch's suspension is he still worth top 20? interesting both of you dont have bush...you really think thomas is going to take over that much...if so...man would i be happy adp forte steven jackson turner LT MJD portis westbrook marion barber chris johnson jacobs deangelo williams bush gore kevin smith addai lynch ronnie brown slaton Pierre thomas Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
kmbryant09 1 Posted April 30, 2009 Ok I'll give it a try (I play .5 PPR league, so keep that in mind) 1. Adrian Peterson - in a league of his own. 2. Michael Turner - not a receiving threat, but his team loves to pound the rock. 3. MJD - expanded role and upgraded OLine should mean a big year 4. Matt Forte - Cutler will open up the run game, but take away touches from Forte 5. DeAngelo Williams - I know JStew is there, but he was also there last year? 6. Steven Jackson - if he stays healthy, should be a top5 back 7. Chris Johnson - ultra-talented on run heavy team 8. LaDanian Tomlinson - he's got some left in his tank for one more decent year 9. Frank Gore - a do-it-all RB who will get his touches 10. Steve Slaton - explosive back who can do everything 11. Brandon Jacobs - an absolute beast who should get more carries without Ward 12. Brian Westbrook - think he's looking at more of a timeshare than we think...for a passhappy offense 13. Marion Barber - should bounce back but big-play F. Jones will take a ton of touches away 14. Clinton Portis - talented, but is old and will wear down as always 15. Kevin Smith - slightly upgraded offense, he should get the touches to produce top15 16. Reggie Bush/P. Thomas - I think both are valuable in their own ways. 17. Ryan Grant - did everyone forget about him? 18. Joseph Addai/D. Brown - RBs will always be productive in Indy and i think Brown will be special 19. K. Moreno - with a new system/coach/QB, Denver should run the ball more. 20. D. Ward - I know he's in a timeshare, but I think he's too good not to get 240+ carries Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
WhiteWonder 2,734 Posted April 30, 2009 did you break them down in groups of 5 for a reason or are your tiers that neat? Im gonna tier mine 1. ADP 2. MJD 3. Turner 4. Forte 5. Westbrook 6. DeAngelo 7. S. Jackson 8. Chris Johnson 9. LT2 10. Gore 11. Portis 12. Jacobs 13. Slaton 14. Barber 15. Ronnie Brown 16. Kevin Smith 17. Parker 18. Thomas Jones 19. Pierre Thomas 20. Moreno Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
e-factor 13 Posted May 1, 2009 No PPR 1. Adrian Peterson 2. Deangelo Williams 3. Michael Turner 4. Jones Drew 5. Brian Westbrook 6. LT 7. Chris Johnson 8. Stephen Jackson 9. Frank Gore 10. Brandon Jacobs 11. Steve Slayton 12. Larry Johnson (Just a feeling) 13. Marian Barber 14. Clinton Portis 15. Ronnie Brown 16. Pierre Thomas 17. Kevin Smith 18. Beanie Wells 19. Knowshawn Moreno 20. Ryan Grant I like the old guys, LT and Westbrook to have good years as both should be healthy (from accounts I have heard) going into the season. My third senior citizen to impress this year is Larry Johnson. I like the chiefs short passing game to open up the running lanes for LJ to have a 1500 yard rushing season. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RLLD 4,230 Posted May 1, 2009 Keep them coming boys, the more participation the better the results... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nygiants12 0 Posted May 1, 2009 OK so here goes , Looked over some Strength of Schedule so far here's what I got. 1) AP - Super Stud 2) Turner - 2ND year as #1 3) Forte - Safety Valve for Cutler 4) MJD - All by himself this year ! 5) Chris Johnson - Titans know how to pound the rock 6) Frank Gore - Has the Best SS of any RB 7) De Angelo Williams - Last year was promising 8) LT - Still solid 9) Portis - One huge year left in him 10) Jacobs - Gmen really don't have any other options 11) Westy - Gonna lose carries in a pass happy Offense 12) Steven Jackson - Overrated every year 13) Slayton - Can do it all 14) Barber - Could be top in top 10 , but health/carries scares me 15) Pierre Thomas - Sleeper 16) Grant- Risky 17) Bush - After thought 18) Brown - May be wrong about him , let somebody else take gamble 19) Parker - Darn good 19Th rb ! 20) Thomas Jones - No way repeats last season ! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Super Cubs 154 Posted May 2, 2009 1. A Peterson 2. MJD 3. S Jackson 4. M Turner 5. S Slaton 6. D Williams 7. M Forte 8. Westbrook 9. B Jacobs 10. L Tomlinson 11. L Johnson 12. K Smith 13. MB3 14. Portis 15. C Johnson 16. D Ward 17. R Brown 18. Grant 19. R Bush 20. L White Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Saint Elistan 106 Posted May 3, 2009 Wow, you guys are really undervaluing Frank Gore. Three straight 1000+ yard seasons, now in a power running scheme, got a run blocking FB back on the roster, drafted a superior blocking TE, with perhaps the softest schedule in the game, and Bruce / Crabtree / Morgan / Hill / Davis to open up the running game? I can only hope he falls this far on draft days. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
pee-diddy 27 Posted May 4, 2009 Super Cubs, no Frank Gore in top 20? Really? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nygiants12 0 Posted May 4, 2009 Super Cubs, no Frank Gore in top 20? Really? Yea that's a head scratcher , LJ over Gore ? If there ever was a year for Gore to blow up , then this is the time. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Super Cubs 154 Posted May 4, 2009 Super Cubs, no Frank Gore in top 20? Really? Honestly he slipped my mind. There are some new names and player movement up and down the list that I over looked him. I would have him around the 10, 11, or 12 area. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jdon 28 Posted May 4, 2009 no ppr the elite top 6: stand apart sjax ADP Forte MJD CJ3 m. turner rounding out the top ten: Tier II: solid production Portis Jacobs Beanie Wells Gore The other significant backs: 11. Kevin Smith 12. Ryan Grant 13. LT 14. westy 15. McFadden 16. MBIII 17. Ronnie Brown 18 Pierre Thomas 19 deangelo williams 20. Benson - should surprise 21. LJ 22. slaton I cheated and ranked 22 as that is how many 'quality backs I think there are in this draft... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Doozer 0 Posted May 5, 2009 .5 PPR League Tier 1 (The YAAAAAAAAAAY I got that mother dude draftees.) MJD (Commitment to the Oline in the draft/FA, void of competition, signing of T. Holt's bent finger.) ADP (Long as Childress is head coach he will never put up the ridiculous numbers he's capable of, question at center.) Forte (Cutler can only increase his production, and likewise, Cutler has never had a back of his talent to work with (Hillis had good hands though.) Gore (Great scheme, coach dedicated to the run, Morgan/Crabtree/Bruce should be solid but not spectacular receiving crew. Bonus points if Shaun Hill is named starter (imo). Tier 2 (The Okay, I'm really happy with this draftees.) D. Williams (Solid young O-line; Kalil, Otah, Gross all under 30, going to get better as they mesh. John Fox's reliance on the Vet back, healthy Steve Smith.) M.Turner (376 carries last season worries me, no threat to catch the ball... one year wonder? At the same time, remarkably talented back with an improving QB/passing attack) LT (Think he has another year in him, could be huge value if he has huge 1st couple games, everyone forgets about 2008 and... trade bait .) CJ3 (Don't know why people are so high on this guy, but not dwill, I would think similar if not worse RBBC with lenwhale, and he is apparently in shape too [not a joke, but yes, it's a joke, no it's really not a joke, it's his contract year.]) Slaton (Plz stay healthy Schaub! Ability to break big run, adequate GL back, and receiving threat make me excited.) Tier 3 (The more question marks than I'd like, but with a little rationalization this pick should be just fine draftees.) Westbrook (Too much of a risk/reward imo) Portis (Disappeared late in season since 2006.) Jacobs (Solid production, but production must be limited to stay healthy imo.) Wells (Perfect fit, ridiculously talented, limited competition, should give Cards the burst on the ground they've been looking for.) Ryan Grant (Look to have a rebound year starting healthy/healthy o-line.) MBIII (Not very confident in the Boys at this point in time.) Ronnie Brown (Inconsistency and health.) Reggie Bush (Could be a steal if he stays healthy and can start where he left off in 2008.) Larry Johnson (Seems motivated as his contract isn't guaranteed (or a portion of it), after the suspension for off-field problems. Larry Johnson may like football, but he loves money, expect him to try and stepup.) Tier 4 (I should of taken a RB in the first draftees.) Kevin Smith Benson McFadden/Bush Pierre Thomas Thomas Jones Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nordwave 2 Posted May 5, 2009 My gut-check first round, 12 team, non-PPR. 1. Adrian Peterson 2. Matt Forte 3. Chris Johnson 4. Frank Gore 5. Maurice-Jones Drew 6. Clinton Portis 7. Michael Turner 8. LaDainian Tomlinson 9. Brian Westbrook 10. Steven Jackson 11. Steve Slaton 12. Brandon Jacobs Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BoltAddiction 0 Posted May 5, 2009 No PPR 1. Peterson - Passed his sophmore year and only downside was a slip in TD production from very good to good. 2. DeAngelo - low mileage and great numbers 3. MJD - All the pieces fell into place for him to have a monster year - now its up to the Jags to produce. 4. Tomlinson - Gut - his age wasn't as much a factor as his mind and I think he has soemthing to prove. 5. Westbrook - Until he's dead, he goes no lower. Bucking the trend with two aged vets in the top 10 6. Forte - only topped 100 ypg against Rams, Lions and Colts. This year he has to face Pitt and Balt and the Lions only once (play again in week 17). I also knock sophmores down slightly. 7. Turner - Only reason he drops to 7 is his having carried the ball 370+ times last year. 8. Jacobs - Why not? 9. S.Jackson - hard for me not to place him higher, but he is still on the Rams. 10. Wells - 3 rookies made it into top 10 running backs last year. Wells wasn't drafted in Round 1 to take backseat to Hightower. Next five are completely interchangeable 11. Portis 12. Gore 13. Chris Johnson 14. Barber 15. Slaton 16. K. Smith 17. Bush 18. Grant 19. Donald Brown 20. Lynch Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
nygiants12 0 Posted May 5, 2009 No PPR 1. Peterson - Passed his sophmore year and only downside was a slip in TD production from very good to good. 2. DeAngelo - low mileage and great numbers 3. MJD - All the pieces fell into place for him to have a monster year - now its up to the Jags to produce. 4. Tomlinson - Gut - his age wasn't as much a factor as his mind and I think he has soemthing to prove. 5. Westbrook - Until he's dead, he goes no lower. Bucking the trend with two aged vets in the top 10 6. Forte - only topped 100 ypg against Rams, Lions and Colts. This year he has to face Pitt and Balt and the Lions only once (play again in week 17). I also knock sophmores down slightly. 7. Turner - Only reason he drops to 7 is his having carried the ball 370+ times last year. 8. Jacobs - Why not? 9. S.Jackson - hard for me not to place him higher, but he is still on the Rams. 10. Wells - 3 rookies made it into top 10 running backs last year. Wells wasn't drafted in Round 1 to take backseat to Hightower. Next five are completely interchangeable 11. Portis 12. Gore 13. Chris Johnson 14. Barber 15. Slaton 16. K. Smith 17. Bush 18. Grant 19. Donald Brown 20. Lynch The milage issue with turner does not scare me one bit. LJ carried the ball 336 times in 05 and had a huge 06 season. If anything next year would be the year to be concerned. Now that Ryan has another Big target , I just dont see Turner wearing down this year. I'd still take him with the 2nd pick ! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BunnysBastatrds 2,439 Posted May 5, 2009 I see many of you have undervalued Regie Bush in PPR leagues. I don't blame you based on past performance and injury. We have been hearing here that Bush is coming into camp more prepared and focoused than he ever has. He has also added some weight and spent a lot of time in the film room during the offseason. I wouldn't put him top ten, but he shouldn't fall past fifteen either in a PPR league. Based on what he hasn't done over the last two years, many will pass on him. He may end up being the steal of the draft. Teams will be focusing more on Brees. Add in a healthy wide receivers core and Shockey, it should open things up for Bush. The Saints didn't draft an offensive player in the draft. Deuce is gone and Pierre Thomas is prone to nagging injuries. And so far, they haven't gone after a proven running back. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
WhiteWonder 2,734 Posted May 5, 2009 I see many of you have undervalued Regie Bush in PPR leagues. I don't blame you based on past performance and injury. We have been hearing here that Bush is coming into camp more prepared and focoused than he ever has. He has also added some weight and spent a lot of time in the film room during the offseason. I wouldn't put him top ten, but he shouldn't fall past fifteen either in a PPR league. Based on what he hasn't done over the last two years, many will pass on him. He may end up being the steal of the draft. Teams will be focusing more on Brees. Add in a healthy wide receivers core and Shockey, it should open things up for Bush. The Saints didn't draft an offensive player in the draft. Deuce is gone and Pierre Thomas is prone to nagging injuries. And so far, they haven't gone after a proven running back. id like to see it before i believe it, what is the team going to say? Reggie Bush is less motivated this year or just as equally motivated, i.e. content with being just as good as he is....? he will end up being good value as a high upside guy and someone will get him at a good price... I even hope its me in a few drafts but I'm not sure I can risk drafting him as a top 15 back. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The Soilost 28 Posted May 5, 2009 What a bunch of amateurs. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Doozer 0 Posted May 5, 2009 What a bunch of amateurs. How are we amateurs? Which picks don't you like? Please try and stay constructive in your criticism. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
msinn 1 Posted May 5, 2009 How are we amateurs? Which picks don't you like? Please try and stay constructive in your criticism. Its ok because you are new. You have no idea of the powers of the Soilost. Brandon Stokley FTW!!! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The Soilost 28 Posted May 5, 2009 How are we amateurs? Which picks don't you like? Please try and stay constructive in your criticism. Son, when you've been doing this as long as I have - and have been as successful as I have - you don't have to answer these kinds of insulting questions. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Little Big Head 6 Posted May 5, 2009 Son, when you've been doing this as long as I have - and have been as successful as I have - you don't have to answer these kinds of insulting questions. I think most of your projections/predictions usually suck. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BoltAddiction 0 Posted May 6, 2009 What a bunch of amateurs. While I hate to agree with this comment, the truth is that I was not paid for my opinion, so by definition I am an amateur. Good job nailing me. I can't speak for the others however. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
e-factor 13 Posted May 6, 2009 One thing that is really jumping out to me is the wide range of opinions of Deangelo Williams. He is all over the board from top 2 to 19-20 range. Unusual for a guy who finished number one (non ppr) last year. I realize that it was a break out year and Stewart is around, but my god, the guy showed an amazing combination of power and breakaway speed. Just can't see him finishng outside the top 10 unless injured. Anyway............. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
kmbryant09 1 Posted May 6, 2009 One thing that is really jumping out to me is the wide range of opinions of Deangelo Williams. He is all over the board from top 2 to 19-20 range. Unusual for a guy who finished number one (non ppr) last year. I realize that it was a break out year and Stewart is around, but my god, the guy showed an amazing combination of power and breakaway speed. Just can't see him finishng outside the top 10 unless injured. Anyway............. I agree, I think DWill is one of the hardest RBs to project this year...but I think his range should go from #2-10ish. I hear everyone saying how JStewart is gonna take over, or he is going to emerge as a RBBC in Carolina, but I don't think people realize how much of a role JStew played last year...THE GUY HAD 184 CARRIES, 836 YARDS, AND 10 TDs - that's not a 3rd down role, thats part of a RBBC...I know it's not 50/50 with DWill, but Jstew certainly took a chunk of stats away from DWill last year Bottom line is this: the Panthers can flat out run the ball, and they flat out WANT to run the ball...They have a dominant OLine, and 2 talented backs (with enough weapons in the air to keep DEFs honest). I understand that JStew might get more of a 50/50 split then last year, but the 2 combined for 450 carries, 2400 yards, and 28 TDs on the ground. Even if DWill is only getting 50% of that (worst case scenario), I'll take 1,200 yards and 14 TDs in the top 5 of a draft anyday Now I don't think they'll duplicate those stats, but my point was to demonstrate how much of the share Stewart had already received last year. I don't think anyone's expecting a repeat performance from DWill, but I don't think its fair to say his production will be severely limited/reduced because of JStew. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Little Big Head 6 Posted May 6, 2009 I agree, I think DWill is one of the hardest RBs to project this year...but I think his range should go from #2-10ish. I hear everyone saying how JStewart is gonna take over, or he is going to emerge as a RBBC in Carolina, but I don't think people realize how much of a role JStew played last year...THE GUY HAD 184 CARRIES, 836 YARDS, AND 10 TDs - that's not a 3rd down role, thats part of a RBBC...I know it's not 50/50 with DWill, but Jstew certainly took a chunk of stats away from DWill last year Bottom line is this: the Panthers can flat out run the ball, and they flat out WANT to run the ball...They have a dominant OLine, and 2 talented backs (with enough weapons in the air to keep DEFs honest). I understand that JStew might get more of a 50/50 split then last year, but the 2 combined for 450 carries, 2400 yards, and 28 TDs on the ground. Even if DWill is only getting 50% of that (worst case scenario), I'll take 1,200 yards and 14 TDs in the top 5 of a draft anyday Now I don't think they'll duplicate those stats, but my point was to demonstrate how much of the share Stewart had already received last year. I don't think anyone's expecting a repeat performance from DWill, but I don't think its fair to say his production will be severely limited/reduced because of JStew. I think the reason for DWs range in value is due to the insane amount of TDs Carolina scored on the ground last year and long odds to duplicate that + Stewart emerging as a top shelf talent in the same backfield. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
kutulu 1,676 Posted May 6, 2009 What a bunch of amateurs. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
kmbryant09 1 Posted May 6, 2009 I think the reason for DWs range in value is due to the insane amount of TDs Carolina scored on the ground last year and long odds to duplicate that + Stewart emerging as a top shelf talent in the same backfield. Yeah - like I said, I don't expect duplicate #'s, but why is everyone worried about JStew - like I said before he was a prominent back last year, and don't forget that DWill was a 1st round pick himself...and uhhhhh put up the best RB numbers last year, so I don't think he's gonna lose his job based on talent... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Zackattack 0 Posted May 6, 2009 I think most of your projections/predictions usually suck. LBH is dead on. You pick one good pick out of ten and you love to pat yourself on the back. I believe you get to much credit for one or two lucky picks through the years. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The Soilost 28 Posted May 6, 2009 LBH is dead on. You pick one good pick out of ten and you love to pat yourself on the back. I believe you get to much credit for one or two lucky picks through the years. Here's a suggestion for your sorry, non-believing ass: Just ask all the members here about how they won championships the past few years using my rankings. Maybe you should go back to playing fantasy badminton or something. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Zackattack 0 Posted May 6, 2009 Here's a suggestion for your sorry, non-believing ass: Just ask all the members here about how they won championships the past few years using my rankings. Maybe you should go back to playing fantasy badminton or something. I have enough success in my money leagues without your help. I have seen your ranking over the last few years. You make a few good picks but that's about it. You try the shock theory and of course you hit on a few. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Zackattack 0 Posted May 6, 2009 look at these picks soloist.... QB's 2,3,4,5,8 and 10 were all bad picks. That's 40%. RB's 1,4,6 and 8 did not perform well. Bush did very well early and got hurt so he was incomplete. I will give you 50% on that. WR's 3,4 and 10 sucked. Moss was far from #1. I will giver your credit for Roddy White and Bowe. Recievers you hit maybe 60%. I will take my own chances thank you. QB's you should be way better. I took Rivers in both big money leagues and Rodgers and warner in one or the other too. Thank god I didn't use your advise there. QUARTERBACK 1.) Jay Cutler – He won’t be Cultering the cheese in the Mile High thin air 2.) Derek Anderson - Derek brings a domino effect to this offense. 3.) Jake Delhomme – Delhomme, Delhomme on the range … 4.) Tom Brady - The Brady Bunch rides again. 5.) Carson Palmer – Arson Carson gonna burn it up. 6.) Peyton Manning — It’s still Peyton’s place. 7.) Drew Brees — This Brees is Category 5. 8.) David Garrard — Get hard for Garrard. 9.) Aaron Rogers — Reader for some Farve beans and a fine chianti. F-f-f-f-f-f-f … 10.) Jason Campbell — Soup is good food. RUNNING BACK 1.) Marion Barber III — With that girly first name, you know he’s tough. 2.) Michael Turner — Yep. 3.) Reggie Bush — You read it here first, ladies. 4.) Selvin Young — Selvin smellvin! 5.) LaDainian Tomlinson — Still good. 6.) Ricky Williams — With the bong in storage, he’ll regain form. 7.) Adrian Peterson — Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarian! 8.) Marshawn Lynch — Kicking ass for Jesus. 9.) Matt Forte — Runnin’ is this man’s forte! 10.) Frank Gore — Frankin’ and spankin’ WIDE RECEIVER 1.) Randy Moss — Obvious. 2.) Andre Johnson — This Johnson is Hollywood swingin’ 3.) Marvin Harrison — Starvin’ for glory. 4.) Santonio Holmes — Will surprise some people. 5.) Roddy White — Roddy ain’t shoddy. 6.) Dwayne Bowe — He’ll Bowe-tie defenders. 7.) TJ Houshmandzadeh – GAZOONTIGHT!!!! 8.) Wes Welker — Wes is no wuss. 9.) Terrell Owens — Terrell ain’t no Cheryl. 10.) Reggie Brown — God of the gridiron. Well, that’s it folks. Good luck. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jdon 28 Posted May 8, 2009 look at these picks soloist.... QB's 2,3,4,5,8 and 10 were all bad picks. That's 40%. RB's 1,4,6 and 8 did not perform well. Bush did very well early and got hurt so he was incomplete. I will give you 50% on that. WR's 3,4 and 10 sucked. Moss was far from #1. I will giver your credit for Roddy White and Bowe. Recievers you hit maybe 60%. I will take my own chances thank you. QB's you should be way better. I took Rivers in both big money leagues and Rodgers and warner in one or the other too. Thank god I didn't use your advise there. QUARTERBACK 1.) Jay Cutler – He won’t be Cultering the cheese in the Mile High thin air 2.) Derek Anderson - Derek brings a domino effect to this offense. 3.) Jake Delhomme – Delhomme, Delhomme on the range … 4.) Tom Brady - The Brady Bunch rides again. 5.) Carson Palmer – Arson Carson gonna burn it up. 6.) Peyton Manning — It’s still Peyton’s place. 7.) Drew Brees — This Brees is Category 5. 8.) David Garrard — Get hard for Garrard. 9.) Aaron Rogers — Reader for some Farve beans and a fine chianti. F-f-f-f-f-f-f … 10.) Jason Campbell — Soup is good food. RUNNING BACK 1.) Marion Barber III — With that girly first name, you know he’s tough. 2.) Michael Turner — Yep. 3.) Reggie Bush — You read it here first, ladies. 4.) Selvin Young — Selvin smellvin! 5.) LaDainian Tomlinson — Still good. 6.) Ricky Williams — With the bong in storage, he’ll regain form. 7.) Adrian Peterson — Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarian! 8.) Marshawn Lynch — Kicking ass for Jesus. 9.) Matt Forte — Runnin’ is this man’s forte! 10.) Frank Gore — Frankin’ and spankin’ WIDE RECEIVER 1.) Randy Moss — Obvious. 2.) Andre Johnson — This Johnson is Hollywood swingin’ 3.) Marvin Harrison — Starvin’ for glory. 4.) Santonio Holmes — Will surprise some people. 5.) Roddy White — Roddy ain’t shoddy. 6.) Dwayne Bowe — He’ll Bowe-tie defenders. 7.) TJ Houshmandzadeh – GAZOONTIGHT!!!! 8.) Wes Welker — Wes is no wuss. 9.) Terrell Owens — Terrell ain’t no Cheryl. 10.) Reggie Brown — God of the gridiron. Well, that’s it folks. Good luck. holy shiit those picks sucked... jdon Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Wuerffel for MVP 0 Posted May 8, 2009 Did he really say "Reggie Brown - God of the gridiron"? And Selvin Young at #4? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RLLD 4,230 Posted May 9, 2009 :lol: A ranking thread with some hilarity, kudos my frineds..... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bones40 0 Posted May 9, 2009 I'm kind of surprised everyone has ADP locked in at number one. In my leage (PPR) he finished outside the top 5 in both total points and points per game. Add into that he's been banged up every year, always fighting an injury and I just don't know. I just found out I have the number one overall pick this year and so far, Forte is the no brainer for #1 overall. Don't get me wrong, I do think ADP is a stud, I just don't think I can pass up a complete back like Forte who was a rookie last year and was second in total points by .4 to DWill and tied for 1st with DWill in PPG. He's a vet this year, he has Cutler to open up the run game and a vastly improved o-line...if he stays healthy I see no reason why all his numbers won't sky rocket. For me, at this point, Forte is a no brainer #1 overall. If I was in a non PPR league I might go with ADP, I suppose. But I'd be looking hard at Forte, Turner and MJD too. If Favre signs with the Vikes, I may have to re-evaluate things, but I don't foresee it changing my mind. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
triple_f 0 Posted May 10, 2009 I like the depth at RB this year. I have always drafted a QB late, stocking up on RB's and WR's early, but I think some good value will be had in later rounds this year. I put Mendenhall at 20. I know he is totally unproven, getting hurt week 4, playing in basically 2 games, but I see him as a nice sleeper. Don't get me wrong, I won't be drafting him where I have him ranked...might take a late round flier on him. PPR Jones-Drew - tied with LT for most TD's since 2006 with Taylor taking touches...20 TD's in 2009? ADP - stud...not great in PPR, but his number's make up for it Forte - will be Cutler's safety valve...great hands/PPR stud Turner - great numbers as the #1 last year...offense not going to stall DeAngelo - as said above, Carolina flat out like to run...and can LT2 - chip on his shoulder Westbrook - every year we say it's the year he drops off...hasn't happened yet, has to go top 7 til he does Barber - Jerry Jones will make sure the boys score...see Barber getting his SJax - needs to play a full season...but nice PPG in PPR Chris Johnson - great break away speed...and Tennessee loves to run Gore - 2006 numbers...312/1695/8/ - 61/485/1...see 250/1500/8 - 40/250/3 Jacobs - beast if he can stay on the field Bush - PPR beast if he can stay on the field...I wouldn't draft him top 20 Ronnie Brown - Parcell's knows how to build a team...someone needs to score Addai - if he can get healthy...he still has Peyton K Smith - good talent...sleeper Slaton - will be in RBBC...great in PPR last year Portis - still has a year or two left JStew - will get 200/900/8 Mendenhall - see Parker getting hurt and Mendenhall taking over and doing well 20+ Larry Johnson - could have put him higher...motivated Grant - the potential is there...scares me though Thomas - will get his touches in great offense in NO...goal line back Wells - RBBC with Hightower? Great skill set in great O Moreno - who knows what McDaniels will do next?...at least the Rat is out of Denver (or is he) D Ward - gonna be interesting to see what he does in TB McFadden - Oak need to step it up Benson - with healthy Palmer and Ocho being the true #1, maybe they regain old form? late round flier Share this post Link to post Share on other sites