2009 Geek Consensus Rankings Voting Thread: QUARTERBACKS

[Mike FF Today 608]

The Geek Consensus Rankings are back! Fumbleweed needs a break this year, so I'll tally up the numbers in his absence.

• Please use this thread to vote for your Top 20 QBs for the 2009 season - redraft.
  
• Redraft League, Standard Performance / FF Today scoring should be used to rank the players - NO PPR!
  
• Voting will last until midnight PM CDT on Saturday, 8/22
  
• Once the voting is over, this thread will be closed and results tabulated.
  
• Traditional polling measures will be used to determine the results
  

Thanks in advance for your participation! We hope this proves to be a helpful resource in establishing a baseline for your upcoming drafts.

[Mike FF Today 608]

1. Tom Brady, NE

2. Drew Brees, NO

3. Peyton Manning, IND

4. Aaron Rodgers, GB

5. Donovan McNabb, PHI

6. Kurt Warner, ARI

7. Philip Rivers, SD

8. Tony Romo, DAL

9. Matt Schaub, HOU

10. David Garrard, JAX

11. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

12. Matt Ryan, ATL

13. Trent Edwards, BUF

14. Carson Palmer, CIN

15. Jay Cutler, CHI

16. Matt Cassel, KC

17. Brett Favre, MIN

18. Eli Manning, NYG

19. Matt Hasselbeck, SEA

20. Joe Flacco, BAL

[Bishop82 61]

1. Tom Brady, NE

2. Drew Brees, NO

3. Peyton Manning, IND

4. Philip Rivers, SD

5. Aaron Rodgers, GB

6. Donovan McNabb, PHI

7. Jay Cutler, CHI

8. Matt Schaub, HOU

9. Carson Palmer, CIN

10. Tony Romo, DAL

11. Matt Ryan, ATL

12. Kurt Warner/Matt Leinart, ARI

13. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

14. Trent Edwards, BUF

15. David Garrard, JAC

16. Matt Hasselbeck, SEA

17. Eli Manning, NYG

18. Brett Favre, MIN

19. Brady Quinn, CLE

20. Jake Delhomme, CAR

[Grizzly 0]

1 Tom Brady

2 Drew Brees

3 Peyton Manning

4 Aaron Rodgers

5 Philip Rivers

6 Kurt Warner

7 Carson Palmer

8 Donovan McNabb

9 Tony Romo

10 Matt Hasselbeck

11 Matt Schaub

12 Brett Favre

13 Matt Ryan

14 Jay Cutler

15 Ben Roethlisberger

16 Trent Edwards

17 Eli Manning

18 David Garrard

19 Matt Cassel

20 Joe Flacco

[DetroitGodfather1 0]

1 - Drew Brees

2 - Kurt Warner

3 - Tom Brady

4 - Aaron Rodgers

5- Phillip Rivers

6 - Peyton Manning

7 - Donovan Mcnabb

8 - Carson Palmer

9 - Matt Schaub

10 - Tony Romo

11 - Matt Hasselbeck

12 - Matt Ryan

13 - Ben Rothlisberger

14 - Trent Edwards

15 - Joe Flacco

16 - Jay Cutler

17 - Brett Favre

18 - David Garrard

19 - Culpepper/Stafford

20 - Matt Cassel

[BunnysBastatrds 1,920]

1. Tom Brady, NE

2. Drew Brees, NO

3. Peyton Manning, IND

4. Aaron Rodgers, GB

5. Donovan McNabb, PHI

6. Kurt Warner, ARI

7. Philip Rivers, SD

8. Tony Romo, DAL

9. Matt Schaub, HOU

10. David Garrard, JAX

11. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

12. Matt Ryan, ATL

13. Trent Edwards, BUF

14. Carson Palmer, CIN

15. Jay Cutler, CHI

16. Matt Cassel, KC

17. Brett Favre, MIN

18. Eli Manning, NYG

19. Matt Hasselbeck, SEA

20. Joe Flacco, BAL

 

 

This is the third year you have ranked David Garrard in the top ten or close to it. I drafted him the last two years and he was one of the most frustrating QB's to own. The bad weeks far outweighed the good weeks. To inconsistent to be ranked in the top ten, imo. Why all the love? Convince me this year he will be top ten. Thanks.

[Dr. Octopus 0]

1 Drew Brees

2 Tom Brady

3 Peyton Manning

4 Tony Romo

5 Kurt Warner

6 Aaron Rodgers

7 Carson Palmer

8 Phillip Rivers

9 Jay Cutler

10 Donovan McNabb

11 Matt Cassell

12 Matt Shaub

13 Daunte Culpepper

14 David Garrard

15 Ben Roethlisberger

16 Brett Favre

17 Eli Manning

18 Kyle Orton

19 Matt Hasselbeck

20 Matt Ryan

[Phurfur 70]

1 Brees, Drew

2 Brady, Tom

3 Rodgers, Aaron

4 Rivers, Philip

5 Manning, Peyton

6 Warner, Kurt

7 Romo, Tony

8 McNabb, Donovan

9 Palmer, Carson

10 Hasselbeck, Matt

11 Schaub, Matt

12 Cutler, Jay

13 Roethlisberger, Ben

14 Cassel, Matt

15 Ryan, Matt

16 Manning, Eli

17 Flacco, Joe

18 Favre, Brett

19 Garrard, David

20 Orton, Kyle

[mobb_deep 917]

1  Tom Brady

2  Drew Brees

3  Peyton Manning

4  Aaron Rodgers

5  Philip Rivers

6  Tony Romo

7  Kurt Warner

8  Donovan McNabb

9  Matt Schaub

10  Carson Palmer

11  Ben Roeth

12  Jay Cutler

13  Matt Ryan

14  Matt Hasselbeck

15  David Garrard

16  Brett Favre

17  Eli Manning

18  Matt Cassel

19  Trent Edwards

20  Joe Flacco

[RamslovaMartzhata 3]

1. Drew Brees, NO

2. Tom Brady, NE

3. Aaron Rodgers, GB

4. Peyton Manning, IND

5. Donovan McNabb, PHI

6. Kurt Warner, ARI

7. Philip Rivers, SD

8. Tony Romo, DAL

9. Carson Palmer, CIN

10. Matt Schaub, HOU

11. Matt Hasselbeck, SEA

12. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

13. Matt Ryan, ATL

14. Trent Edwards, BUF

15. Brett Favre, MIN

16. Jay Cutler, CHI

17. Matt Cassel, KC

18. Eli Manning, NYG

19. Matthew Stafford, DET

20. Mark Sanchez, NYJ

[Pocket Pair Professor 0]

1-Peyton Manning

2-Drew Brees

3-Kurt warner

4-Aaron Rodgers

5-Tom Brady

6-Donovan McNabb

7-Phillip Rivers

8-Jay Cutler

9-Tony Romo

10-Brett Farve

11-Matt Hasselback

12-Carson Palmer

13-Matt Ryan

14-Kyle Orton

15-Eli Manning

16-Trent Edwards

17-David Gerrard

18-Matt Schaub

19-Jason Campbell

20-Joe Flacco

[Melissa Stark 1]

1. Drew Brees, NO

2. Tom Brady, NE

3. Peyton Manning, IND

4. Aaron Rodgers, GB

5. Donovan McNabb, PHI

6. Kurt Warner, ARI

7. Philip Rivers, SD

8. Matt Schaub, HOU

9. Tony Romo, DAL

10. Matt Ryan, ATL

11. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

12. Trent Edwards, BUF

13. Jay Cutler, CHI

14. Carson Palmer, CIN

15. Matt Cassel, KC

16. Kyle Orton

17. Eli Manning, NYG

18. Matt Hasselbeck, SEA

19. Joe Flacco, BAL

20. Mark Sanchez, NYJ

[Cuse9 128]

1. Tom Brady

2. Drew Brees

3. Kurt Warner

4. Aaron Rodgers

5. Peyton Manning

6. Matt Schaub

7. Philip Rivers

8. Tony Romo

9. Donovan McNabb

10. Carson Palmer

11. Matt Ryan

12. Brett Favre

13. Matt Hasselbeck

14. Matt Cassell

15. Jake Delhomme

16. Brady Quinn

17. Trent Edwards

18. Ben Roethlisberger

19. Kyle Orton

20. Eli Manning

[IndyFan 2]

1 Brees, Drew

2 Brady, Tom

3 Manning, Peyton

4 Warner, Kurt

5 Romo, Tony

6 Rivers, Philip

7 Rodgers, Aaron

8 McNabb, Donovan

9 Schaub, Matt

10 Palmer, Carson

11 Manning, Eli

12 Cutler, Jay

13 Favre, Brett

14 Cassel, Matt

15 Ryan, Matt

16 Roethlisberger, Ben

17 Flacco, Joe

18 Edwards, Trent

19 Matt Hasselbeck

20 Jake Delhomme

[WhiteWonder 2,172]

1. Drew Brees

2. Tom Brady

3. Peyton Manning

4. Phillip Rivers

5. Aaron Rodgers

6. Donovan McNabb

7. Carson Palmer

8. Matt Schaub

9. Tony Romo

10. Kurt Warner

11. Jay Cutler

12. Matt Ryan

13. Matt Hasselbeck

14. Matt Cassel

15. Eli Manning

16. David Garrard

17. Trent Edwards

18. Jake Delhomme

19. Ben Roethlisberger

20. Brett Favre

[flatidea 0]

1. Tom Brady, NE

2. Drew Brees, NO

3. Peyton Manning, IND

4. Aaron Rodgers, GB

5. Philip Rivers, SD

6. Kurt Warner, ARI

7. Matt Schaub, HOU

8. Donovan McNabb, PHI

9. Matt Ryan, ATL

10. Tony Romo, DAL

11. Jay Cutler, CHI

12. Matt Ryan, ATL

13. Carson Palmer, CIN

14. Brett Favre, MIN

15. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

16. Matt Hasselbeck, SEA

17. Trent Edwards, BUF

18. Matt Cassel, KC

19. Jake Delhomme, CAR

20. Jason Campbell, WAS

[freighttrain 0]

1. Tom Brady

2. Drew Brees

3. Aaron Rodgers

4. Peyton Manning

5. Kurt Warner

6. Philip Rivers

7. Matt Schaub

8. Donovan McNabb

9. Tony Romo

10. Matt Ryan

11. Carson Palmer

12. Brett Favre

13. Matt Cassel

14. Trent Edwards

15. Ben Roethlisberger

16. Jake Delhomme

17. David Garrard

18. Matt Hasselbeck

19. Shaun Hill

20. Eli Manning

[Ilov80s 0]

1. Brees

2. Brady

3. Rodgers

4. P Manning

5. McNabb

6. Schaub

7. Rivers

8. Warner

9. Hasselback

10. Ryan

11. Romo

12. Palmer

13. Big Ben

14. Favre

15. Flacco

16. Cassel

17. Russell

18. Stafford

19. Edwarrds

20. Culpepper

[Raider 84 29]

1. Brees

2. Brady

3. Peyton

4. Warner

5. Rivers

6. Rodgers

7. Romo

8. Palmer

9. McNabb

10. Schaub

11. Ryan

12. Favre

13. Big Ben

14. Hasselbeck

15. Edwards

16. Cassel

17.Hill

18. Eli

19. Garrard

20.Delhomme

[Bishop82 61]

Jay Cutler didn't make the top 20 in four of these lists???

[RaiderHaters Revenge 3,585]

1. Brady

2. Rivers

3. Rodgers

4. Brees

5. P.Manning

6. Warner

7. Schaub

8. Romo

9. McNabb

10. Ryan

11. Palmer

12. Hasselbeck

13. Favre

14. Delhomme

15. Roethlisberger

16. Edwards

17. Cutlet

18. Pennington

19. Garrard

20. E. Manning

[ronnydobbs 0]

1. Peyton

2. Brees

3. Brady

4. Rodgers

5. McNabb

6. Warner

7. Rivers

8. Palmer

9. Romo

10. Eli

11. Ryan

12. Schaub

13. Big Ben

14. Garrard

15. Edwards

16. Cassel

17.Hasselbeck

18. Favre

19. Flacco

20.Delhomme

[JosephB.Palasky 0]

1. Drew Brees

2. Tom Brady

3. Peyton Manning

4. Aaron Rodgers

5. Matt Schaub

6. Phillip Rivers

7. Tony Romo

8. Carson Palmer

9. Kurt Warner

10. Matt Hasselbeck

11. Donovan McNabb

12. Trent Edwards

13. Ben Roethlisberger

14. Matt Ryan

15. Jay Cutler

16. David Garrard

17. Brett Favre

18. Eli Manning

19. Matt Cassel

20. Matthew Stafford

[carmo911 2]

1. D. Brees

2. T. Brady

3. P. Manning

4. P. Rivers

5. A Rodgers

6. D. Mcnabb

7. K. Warner

8. T. Romo

9. M. Schaub

10. C. Palmer

11. M. Ryan

12. J. Culter

13. M. Hasselback

14. B. Roethlisberger

15. M. Cassel

16. B. Favre

17. J. Delhomme

18. T. Edwards

19. E. Manning

20. S. Hill

[montana 89]

1. brees

2. brady

3. p.manning

4. warner

5. rodgers

6. rivers

7. mcnabb

8. romo

9. schaub

10. palmer

11. ryan

12. cassel

13. cutler

14. e.manning

15. edwards

16. hasselbeck

17. favre

18. orton

19. roethlisberger

20. delhomme

[hellothere 1]

1.T.Brady

2.D.Brees

3.A.Rodgers

4.M.Schaub

5.P.Rivers

6.P.Manning

7.K.Warner

8.M.Hasslebeck

9.B.Roethisberger

10.T.Romo

11.C.Palmer

12.J.Cutler

13.D.Garrard

14.M.Ryan

15.C.Pennington

16.J.Delhomme

17.D.McNabb

18.E.Manning

19.J.Flacco

20.M.Cassel

[9-Route 0]

1 brees

2 rodgers

3 manning

4 rivers

5 warner

6 brady

7 ryan

8 mcfagg

9 hasselbeck

10 stafford

11 palmer

12 romo

13 eli

14 cassel

15 schaub

16 t edwards

17 cutler

18 flacco

19 pennington

20 roth

[Super Cubs 132]

1 Brees

2 Brady

3 Schaub

4 Rogers

5 P Manning

6 McNabb

7 Rivers

8 Warner

9 Palmer

10 Garrard

11 Ryan

12 Hasselbeck

13 Cutler

14 Pennington

15 Flacco

16 Edwards

17 Eli

18 Cassel

19 Hill

20 Orton

[treewarden 1]

1 Aaron Rodgers

2 Drew Brees

3 Tom Brady

4 Peyton Manning

5 Matt Schaub

6 Donovan McNabb

7 Matt Ryan

8 Philip Rivers

9 Carson Palmer

10 Kurt Warner

11 Tony Romo

12 Jay Cutler

13 Matt Hasselbeck

14 Ben Roethlisberger

15 Brett Favre

16 Eli Manning

17 Trent Edwards

18 Jake Delhomme

19 David Garrard

20 Matthew Stanford

[The Moz 69]

1 Tom Brady

2 Drew Brees

3 Peyton Manning

 

4 Aaron Rodgers

5 Philip Rivers

6 Kurt Warner

7 Donovan McNabb

8 Tony Romo

9 Matt Shaub

10 Carson Palmer

11 Jay Cutler

12 Matt Ryan

 

13 Brett Favre

14 David Garrard

15 Ben Rothleisberger

16 Matt Hasselbeck

 

17 Trent Edwards

18 Matt Cassell

19 Eli Manning

20 Joe Flacco

[RLLD 3,455]

1. Drew Brees, NO

2. Tom Brady, NE

3. Peyton Manning, IND

4. Aaron Rodgers, GB

5. Philip Rivers, SD

6. Kurt Warner, ARI

7. Matt Ryan, ATL

8. Tony Romo, DAL

9. Matt Schaub, HOU

10. David Garrard, JAX

11. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

12. Donovan McNabb, PHI

13. Eli Manning, NYG

14. Jay Cutler, CHI

15. Trent Edwards, BUF

16. Matt Cassel, KC

17. Matt Hasselbeck, SEA

18. Carson Palmer, CIN

19. Joe Flacco, BAL

20. Jake Delhomme, CAR

[Gladiators 1,904]

1 Drew Brees

2 Tom Brady

3 Peyton Manning

4 Aaron rodgers

5 Philip Rivers

6 Donovan McNabb

7 Kurt Warner

8 Matt Schaub

9 Tony Romo

10 Matt Ryan

11 Carsen Palmer

12 Jay Cutler

13 Eli Manning

14 Ben Roethlisberger

15 Matt Cassel

16 Brett Favre

17 Trent Edwards

18 Matt Hasselbeck

19 Jake Delhomme

20 David Garrard

[Llexlon 0]

I can't believe that the Pit homers haven't been on here complaining about Big Ben's ranking....they all call in and love him on NFL Network.

[GiantsFan11 0]

1 Drew Brees

2 Tom Brady

3 Peyton Manning

4 Aaron Rodgers

5 Kurt Warner

6 Phillip Rivers

7 Tony Romo

8 Donovan McNabb

9 Matt Ryan

10 Matt Schaub

11 Jay Cutler

12 Ben Rothlisberger

13 Carson Palmer

14 Matt Cassell

15 Eli Manning

16 Matt Hasselbeck

17 David Garrard

18 Trent Edwards

19 Kyle Orton

20 Brett Favre

[BloodySunday 0]

1 Brady

2 Brees

3 Rodgers

4 P Manning

5 Warner

6 McNabb

7 Rivers

8 Romo

9 Schaub

10 Palmer

11 Garrard

12 Cutler

13 Hasselbeck

14 Roethlisberger

15 Ryan

16 Edwards

17 Campbell

18 Orton

19 Pennington

20 E Manning

[King56 0]

I would go with McNabb over Romo. A couple QB's I am staying away from this year are Romo, Cutler, Orton, Cassel. Looking at mock drafts McNabb and Schaub are good value for where they are going. I think Palmer could be a sleeper this year. Picking a QB depends on your leagues scoring. This helped me with my draft. http://www.ehow.com/how_5321222_win-fantasy-football.html