2012 Consensus Rankings Voting Thread: QUARTERBACKS

[Mike FF Today 608]

The Geek Consensus Rankings are back for 2012. worm has graciously offered his services to gather up the results.

 

• Please use this thread to vote for your Top 20 QBs for the 2012 season.
  
• Redraft League, Standard Performance / FF Today scoring should be used to rank the players - NO PPR!
  
• Voting will last until midnight PM PST on Thursday, 8/16
  
• Once the voting is over, the results will be documented then tabulated.
  
• Traditional polling measures will be used to determine the results
  

Thanks in advance for your participation! We hope this proves to be a helpful resource in establishing a baseline for your upcoming drafts.

[Mike FF Today 608]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Tom Brady, NE

3. Matthew Stafford, DET

4. Drew Brees, NO

5. Cam Newton, CAR

6. Michael Vick, PHI

7. Matt Ryan, ATL

8. Eli Manning, NYG

9. Philip Rivers, SD

10. Tony Romo, DAL

11. Peyton Manning, DEN

12. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

13. Robert Griffin III, WAS

14. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

15. Carson Palmer, OAK

16. Josh Freeman, TB

17. Joe Flacco, BAL

18. Andy Dalton, CIN

19. Matt Schaub, HOU

20. Jay Cutler, CHI

[worm 34]

Quick request: if you guys edit your list during the voting period, it would be a BIG help if you noted the date of the edit at the bottom of your post. That way I can get the final rankings out a lot quicker. Thanks!

 

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Tom Brady

3. Matt Stafford

4. Michael Vick

5. Drew Brees

6. Cam Newton

7. Tony Romo

8. Philip Rivers

9. Eli Manning

10. Matt Ryan

11. Robert Griffin III

12. Peyton Manning

13. Ben Roethlisberger

14. Matt Schaub

15. Jay Cutler

16. Josh Freeman

17. Carson Palmer

18. Ryan Fitzpatrick

19. Andy Dalton

20. Andrew Luck

Edited August 15, 2012 by worm

[ralphster 274]

1. Rodgers - GB

2. Brady - NE

3. Brees - NO

4. Stafford - DET

5. Ryan - ATL

6. Vick - PHI

7. Rivers - SD

8. Romo - DAL

9. Newton - CAR

10. P Manning - DEN

11. Cutler - CHI

12. E Manning - NYG

13. Fitzpatrick - BUF

14. Rothlisberger - PIT

15. Palmer - OAK

16. Freeman - TB

17. RG3 - WAS

18. Flacco - BAL

19. Schaub - HOU

20. Dalton - CIN

[carmo911 2]

1. A. Rodgers - GB

2. T. Brady - NE

3. D. Brees - NO

4. M. Stafford - DET

5. M. Ryan - ATL

6. M. Vick - PHI

7. P. Rivers - SD

8. E. Manning - NYG

9. P. Manning - DEN

10. C. Newton - CAR

11. T. Romo - DAL

12. B. Roethlisberger - PIT

13. R. Fitzpatrick - BUF

14. J. Cutler - CHI

15. C. Palmer - OAK

16. J. Flacco - BAL

17. A. Smith - SF

18. A. Dalton - CIN

19. J. Freeman - TB

20. M. Schaub - HOU

[MicktheGreat 1]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Matt Stafford, DET

3. Tom Brady, NE

4. Drew Brees, NO

5. Eli Manning, NYG

6. Peyton Manning, DEN

7. Cam Newton, CAR

8. Tony Romo, DAL

9. Matt Ryan, ATL

10. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

11. Philip Rivers, SD

12. Mike Vick, PHI

13. Jay Cutler, CHI

14. Joe Flacco, BALT

15. Josh Freeman, TB

16. Carson Palmer, OAK

17. Matt Schaub, HOU

18. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

19. Andy Dalton, CIN

20. Robert Griffin III, WASH

[OilFieldTrash 0]

1. Tom Brady, NE

2. Aaron Rodgers, GB

3. Matthew Stafford, DET

4. Drew Brees, NO

5. Eli Manning, NYG

6. Peyton Manning, DEN

7. Matt Ryan, ATL

8. Cam Newton, CAR

9. Carson Palmer, OAK

10. Michael Vick, PHI

11. Jay Cutler, CHI

12. Philip Rivers, SD

13. Tony Romo, DAL

14. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

15. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

16. Josh Freeman, TB

17. Joe Flacco, BAL

18. Robert Griffin III, WAS

19. Matt Schaub, HOU

20. Andy Dalton, CIN

[Phurfur 70]

1 Rodgers, Aaron

2 Brees, Drew

3 Brady, Tom

4 Newton, Cam

5 Stafford, Matthew

6 Manning, Peyton

7 Manning, Eli

8 Rivers, Philip

9 Ryan, Matt

10 Romo, Tony

11 Cutler, Jay

12 Schaub, Matt

13 Vick, Michael

14 Roethlisberger, Ben

15 Bradford, Sam

16 Griffin, Robert III

17 Freeman, Josh

18 Palmer, Carson

19 Fitzpatrick, Ryan

20 Cassel, Matt

[cmh6476 755]

1. Matt Cassel

2. Tom Brady

3. Aaron Rodgers

4. Drew Brees

5. Matt Ryan

6. Jay Cutler

7. Tony Romo

8. Eli Manning

9. Matt Stafford

10. Cam Newton

11. Ben Roethlisberger

12. Peyton Manning

13. Philip Rivers

14. Michael Vick

15. Carson Palmer

16. RGIII

17. Matt Schaub

18. Andrew Luck

19. Matt Flynn

20. Joe Flacco

Edited August 15, 2012 by cmh6476

[UNCDave 0]

1. Brady, Tom

2. Rodgers, Aaron

3. Brees, Drew

4. Vick, Michael

5. Newton, Cam

6. Stafford, Matthew

7. Rivers,Philip

8. Manning, Peyton

9. Ryan, Matt

10. Palmer, Carson

11. Manning, Eli

12. Griffin III, Robert

13. Roethlisberger, Ben

14. Romo, Tony

15. Flacco, Joe

16. Schaub, Matt

17. Smith, Alex

18. Cutler, Jay

19. Fitzpatrick, Ryan

20. Luck, Andrew

[Raider 84 29]

1. Rodgers

2. Stafford

3. Brees

4. Brady

5. Ryan

6. Newton

7. P. Manning

8. E. Manning

9. Rivers

10. Romo

11. Palmer

12. Cutler

13. Fitzpatrick

14. A. Luck

15. M. Vick

16. Schaub

17. Flacco

18. A. Smith

19. Roethlisberger

20. Tebow

[Ace08 11]

1. Tom Brady, NE

2. Aaron Rodgers, GB

3. Drew Brees, NO

4. Matthew Stafford, DET

5. Cam Newton, CAR

6. Michael Vick, PHI

7. Tony Romo, DAL

8. Matt Ryan, ATL

9. Peyton Manning, DEN

10. Eli Manning, NYG

11. Philip Rivers, SD

12. Jay Cutler, CHI

13. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

14. Robert Griffin III, WAS

15. Carson Palmer, OAK

16. Josh Freeman, TB

17. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

18. Joe Flacco, BAL

19. Andy Dalton, CIN

20. Matt Schaub, HOU

[giraldi02 470]

1. Rodgers

2. Brady

3. Brees

4. Stafford

5. Rivers

6. Newton

7. Romo

8. Vick

9. Eli Manning

10. Ryan

11. Cutler

12. Peyton Manning

13. Roethlisberger

14. Freeman

15. RGIII

16. Fitzpatrick

17. Palmer

18. Luck

19. Dalton

20. Flacco

[vegassandwich227 0]

1 Rodgers

2 Brady

3 Newton

4 Brees

5 Stafford

6 Vick

7 Ryan

8 Romo

9 Eli

10 Ben

11 Rivers

12 Freeman

13 Fitzpatrick

14 Dalton

15 RG3

16 Schaub

17 Flacco

18 Manning

19 A Smith

20 Luck

[Ditka vs. ______ 0]

1 Aaron Rodgers

2 Tom Brady

3 Drew Brees

4 Matthew Stafford

5 Cam Newton

6 Philip Rivers

7 Tony Romo

8 Michael Vick

9 Matt Ryan

10 Eli Manning

11 Peyton Manning

12 Robert Griffin III

13 Ben Roethlisberger

14 Josh Freeman

15 Matt Schaub

16 Ryan Fitzpatrick

17 Joe Flacco

18 Jay Cutler

19 Andy Dalton

20 Alex Smith (QB)

[mobb_deep 917]

1) Aaron Rodgers

2) Tom Brady

3) Drew Brees

4) Matthew Stafford

5) Cam Newton

6) Michael Vick

7) Matt Ryan

8) Peyton Manning

9) Tony Romo

10) Eli Manning

11) Philip Rivers

12) Robert Griffin

13) Jay Cutler

14) Josh Freeman

15) Matt Schaub

16) Ben Roethlisberger

17) Carson Palmer

18) Andrew Luck

19) Andy Dalton

20) Joe Flacco

[freighttrain 0]

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Tom Brady

3. Drew Brees

4. Matt Stafford

5. Matt Ryan

6. Cam Newton

7. Michael Vick

8. Eli Manning

9. Tony Romo

10. Philip Rivers

11. Peyton Manning

12. Matt Schaub

13. Robert Griffin III

14. Ryan Fitzpatrick

15. Josh Freeman

16. Andrew Luck

17. Andy Dalton

18. Jay Cutler

19. Carson Palmer

20. Ben Roethlisberger

[robb 71]

1 Rogers

2 Brady

3 Stafford, Det

4 Brees, NO

5 Newton, Car

6 Rivers

7 Romo

8 Manning,Denver

9 Cutler, Chi

10 Ryan, Atl

11 Manning,Eli

12 Vick

13 Rothlesberger

14 Schaub,Hou

15 Freeman, TB

16 Dalton,Cin

17 Griffin,®, Wash

18 Fitzpatrick,Buf

19 Bradford,SL

20 Palmer

[steelers2101 7]

1. Matt Cassel

 

 

Nobody else noticed this?

 

I imagine it's just to get Cassel a few extra points in the voting in an effort to have him move up the ranks....or do you actually sincerely believe he'll be the top QB?

[Flgatorguy87 160]

Nobody else noticed this?

 

I imagine it's just to get Cassel a few extra points in the voting in an effort to have him move up the ranks....or do you actually sincerely believe he'll be the top QB?

 

 

Homer...a bad one at that

[bc91 0]

1. Rodgers

2. Brees

3. Brady

4. Stafford

5. Romo

6. Ryan

7. Rivers

8. P.Manning

9. E.Manning

10. Newton

11. Vick

12. Cutler

13. Roethlisberger

14. RGIII

15. Luck

16. Pitzpatrick

17. Freeman

18. Palmer

19. Dalton

20. Flacco

[cmh6476 755]

Nobody else noticed this?

 

I imagine it's just to get Cassel a few extra points in the voting in an effort to have him move up the ranks....or do you actually sincerely believe he'll be the top QB?

You got it. No I don't think he'll be in the top 5, but most don't have the guy in the top 20. Barring injury, I don't see how he's not a top 20 qb, but perhaps I'm wrong. Both Hillis and Charles can catch the ball well. Bowe and Baldwin are two steady receivers, another threat in Moeaki is back, oh yeah and the OL improved. This is better than the group around him that helped him get to the Pro Bowl in 2010.

 

It makes sense for him to get a spike since he isn't getting any love. This guy could be a real bargain in most leagues, and somebody I wouldn't mind having around if simply nothing more than a bye week filler.

[IMMensaMind 459]

1. Tom Brady, NE

2. Aaron Rodgers, GB

3. Matt Stafford, DET

4. Drew Brees, NO

5. Jay Cutler, CHI

6. Matt Ryan, ATL

7. Philip Rivers, SD

8. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

9. Carson Palmer, OAK

10. Cam Newton, CAR

11. Peyton Manning, DEN

12. Tony Romo, DAL

13. Eli Manning, NYG

14. Mike Vick, PHI

15. Joe Flacco, BALT

16. Josh Freeman, TB

17. Matt Cassel, KC

18. Matt Schaub, HOU

19. Alex Smith , SF

20. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

21. Robert Griffin III, WASH

[worm 34]

You got it. No I don't think he'll be in the top 5, but most don't have the guy in the top 20. Barring injury, I don't see how he's not a top 20 qb, but perhaps I'm wrong. Both Hillis and Charles can catch the ball well. Bowe and Baldwin are two steady receivers, another threat in Moeaki is back, oh yeah and the OL improved. This is better than the group around him that helped him get to the Pro Bowl in 2010.

 

It makes sense for him to get a spike since he isn't getting any love. This guy could be a real bargain in most leagues, and somebody I wouldn't mind having around if simply nothing more than a bye week filler.

cmh, you also have Vick listed twice.

[gcmmidwest 98]

nobody has flynn listed at top 20 ??? pete carroll knows what he's doing & this guy slung 5 td's when he replaced rodgers

you heard it hear 1st.....!!!

[jerryskids 5,206]

You got it. No I don't think he'll be in the top 5, but most don't have the guy in the top 20. Barring injury, I don't see how he's not a top 20 qb, but perhaps I'm wrong. Both Hillis and Charles can catch the ball well. Bowe and Baldwin are two steady receivers, another threat in Moeaki is back, oh yeah and the OL improved. This is better than the group around him that helped him get to the Pro Bowl in 2010.

 

It makes sense for him to get a spike since he isn't getting any love. This guy could be a real bargain in most leagues, and somebody I wouldn't mind having around if simply nothing more than a bye week filler.

Your opinion is fine and all, but the idea of this process is to get the consensus of everyone here. Which means you should put him at 15 or wherever you think he is, and it gets worked into the mix. I might think Skelton can crack the top 20 throwing to Fitz, Floyd, Roberts, Heap, Housler... but I wouldn't put him at #1 to fock up the ratings.

[Bishop82 61]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Tom Brady, NE

3. Drew Brees, NO

4. Matthew Stafford, DET

5. Cam Newton, CAR

6. Matt Ryan, ATL

7. Eli Manning, NYG

8. Michael Vick, PHI

9. Peyton Manning, DEN

10. Jay Cutler, CHI

11. Philip Rivers, SD

12. Tony Romo, DAL

12. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

13. Robert Griffin III, WAS

14. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

15. Andrew Luck, IND

16. Matt Cassel, KC

17. Joe Flacco, BAL

18. Andy Dalton, CIN

19. Matt Schaub, HOU

20. Alex Smith, SF

[PistonSteve 0]

1. Rodgers

2. Brees

3. Brady

4. Stafford

5. Ryan

6. Vick

7. E. Manning

8. P. Manning

9. Newton

10. Rivers

11. Griffin

12. Cutler

13. Palmer

14. Romo

15. Roethlisberger

16. Dalton

17. Freeman

18. Schaub

19. Flacco

20. Luck

[steelers2101 7]

You got it. No I don't think he'll be in the top 5, but most don't have the guy in the top 20. Barring injury, I don't see how he's not a top 20 qb, but perhaps I'm wrong. Both Hillis and Charles can catch the ball well. Bowe and Baldwin are two steady receivers, another threat in Moeaki is back, oh yeah and the OL improved. This is better than the group around him that helped him get to the Pro Bowl in 2010.

 

It makes sense for him to get a spike since he isn't getting any love. This guy could be a real bargain in most leagues, and somebody I wouldn't mind having around if simply nothing more than a bye week filler.

 

I think you might be onto something.

[steelers2101 7]

Your opinion is fine and all, but the idea of this process is to get the consensus of everyone here. Which means you should put him at 15 or wherever you think he is, and it gets worked into the mix. I might think Skelton can crack the top 20 throwing to Fitz, Floyd, Roberts, Heap, Housler... but I wouldn't put him at #1 to fock up the ratings.

 

You're right, but at the same time, if he truly believes Cassel should be much better than everyone else is giving him credit for, he's really only trying to do everyone a favor. KC might be one of the big surprises this year and I, for one, wouldn't have even given a second thought to Cassel if I hadn't seen his odd ranking. That said, he could easily have given him his actual ranking, and created a post about Cassel, but something about ranking Cassel #1 pops out more than any old post.

[JKAP21 0]

1. A. Rogers

2. T. Brady

3. M. Stafford

4. D. Brees

5. C. Newton

6. M. Vick

7. M. Ryan

8. T. Romo

9. P. Rivers

10. P. Manning

11. E. Manning

12. R. Griffin III

13. B. Roethlisberger

14. C. Palmer

15. J. Cutler

16. R. Fitzpatrick

17. M. Schaub

18. M. Flynn

19. A. Luck

20. A. Dalton

[Super Cubs 132]

1. Brees

2. Rogers

3. Stafford

4. Brady

5. Ryan

6. Eli

7. Rivers

8. Newton

9. Peyton

10. Vick

11. Freeman

12. Cutler

13. Dalton

14. Romo

15. Roethlisberger

16. Palmer

17. Schaub

18. RG3

19. Fitzpatrick

20. Flacco

[montana 89]

1. a rod

2. brady

3. brees

4. stafford

5. ryan

6. vick

7. eli

8. cam

9. peyton

10. rivers

11. romo

12. big ben

13. freeman

14. palmer

15. cutler

16. flacco

17. rg3

18. fitz

19. cassel

20. schaub

[David PatteRn 0]

1. Tom Brady, NE
   
2. Aaron Rodgers, GB
   
3. Drew Brees, NO
   
4. Matthew Stafford, DET
   
5. Cam Newton, CAR
   
6. Matt Ryan, ATL
   
7. Michael Vick, PHI
   
8. Tony Romo, DAL
   
9. Eli Manning, NYG
   
10. Peyton Manning, DEN
    
11. Philip Rivers, SD
    
12. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT
    
13. Robert Griffin III, WAS
    
14. Jay Cutler, CHI
    
15. Matt Schaub, HOU
    
16. Carson Palmer, OAK
    
17. Andrew Luck, IND
    
18. Josh Freeman, TB
    
19. Andy Dalton, CIN
    
20. Jake Locker, TEN
    

[worm 34]

Voting is closed.