Could you win a fantasy football championship with an all white team?

[mmmmm...beer 790]

I dunno if a guy could put together a consistant scoring team in a 10 man league full of honkies only.

 

QB would be easy, probably TE as well, and obviously kicker.

 

Your screwed at RB though... and your a Wes Welker injury away from not having enough starters.

 

I don't know enough about defenses around the league if you were going IDP. Maybe someone can help out with that.

 

Hispanics count as white in the census, so it would have to be a league vote if they get in or not.

 

Plus if the other 9 guys could draft whoever they wanted, they'd be stealing the good white guys each round as well.

[vuduchile 1,945]

QB - Pick one

RB - Woodhead

RB - Kuhn

WR - Jordy

WR - Edleman

Flex - Decker? Is he white or just light skinned?

TE - Gronk

K - Pick one

 

This is probably he best you could do.

 

Team D isn't an option.

[Mike Honcho 5,230]

Well, considering I can't win using all the players now, pretty doubtful I'm winning with the Caucasian All-stars.

[BLS 314]

You could FIELD an all white team.

 

You could not WIN with an all white team.

 

 

No, everything is not gonna be "all white".

[mmmmm...beer 790]

Well, considering I can't win using all the players now, pretty doubtful I'm winning with the Caucasian All-stars.

[tanatastic 2,062]

No, the RBs simply would not carry you enough for a season. 1 game? Sure, any team could win the championship since its just dumb luck who scores what, when and how against what your opponent randomly scored.

 

But yea like Mike said, since I cant win now spending 8rs a day doing research and devoting my life to FF like I foolishly do, then any handicap wont be good. I may as well practice for the Rock, paper scissors championship. Its more skill based and fewer variables anyway.

[mmmmm...beer 790]

You could FIELD an all white team.

 

You could not WIN with an all white team.

 

 

No, everything is not gonna be "all white".

I thought this would actually be sorta funny. If you have a friendly redraft league, draft nothing but white guys, don't say anything in the league about it and see if anyone catches on.

 

Have some subtle racist name that could tip off, but not blatently give it away.

 

"The Masters"

"Masta Baiters"

"Cracka"

[ROCKFORD 134]

back in th 90's i thought about drafting all smiths and johnsons.

 

the team would have been competitive.

 

emmitt smith in the first.

[frank 2,290]

Yes, but none of you guys could.

[BunnysBastatrds 2,366]

We had a guy in an auction league years ago that tried it. He'd draft as many white player's and LSU player's as he could. He never came close to winning. The name of his team..............The Confederates.

[the newb 23]

We had a guy in an auction league years ago that tried it. He'd draft as many white player's and LSU player's as he could. He never came close to winning. The name of his team..............The Confederates.

[frank 2,290]

LSU player's

In his defense, he's probably a drunken idiot.

[edjr 6,579]

is Bryant Gumbel a RB or WR?

[edjr 6,579]

Well, considering I can't win using all the players now, pretty doubtful I'm winning with the Caucasian All-stars.

 

and that is assuming no one else drafts any white dudes.

 

think how much last year would have sucked when probably your best position player, Jordy Nelson didn't even play a week.

[Big Guy 1,412]

Haha funny....brings back old memories from a FANBALL team I had. Mike Allstott was the backbone of the team, can't remember anybody else that was on it though. I do believe it was the year that I had 10 freakin' teams and was Commish of three Leagues, craziness!

 

And oh, my team wasn't very good and right now I can't remember the name.

[peenie 1,906]

Nor could you win with an all black team.

[edjr 6,579]

Nor could you win with an all black team.

 

 

you don't need a kicker or a punter to win and Cam Newton did just fine.

[peenie 1,906]

Really, list the all black team.

 

eta,

I can barely think of a player that scored well every single week that wasn't outplayed by some nobody on my opponents team that didn't kick my butt. Sometimes your great player had a bad week. Just cause Cam did great didn't mean your star RB did great. Maybe that was the week the a DEF on your opponents team outscored you by 1 pt. A winning team does not exist without a white player. My kicker has helped win the game for me many times.

 

Caucasian All Stars is a great name.

All Players Matter (black and white members) would be my team name in the Racist League.

 

(is there an all black or white DEF?)

[edjr 6,579]

Really, list the all black team.

 

 

 

Wilson

Peterson/Freeman

A. Brown/J. Jones/Hopkins

J. Reed

 

 

don't need a kicker or a defense with that team

[peenie 1,906]

racists!

 

if i had brady, gronk and beckham and....other members i'd beat you!!!

[edjr 6,579]

racists!

 

if i had brady, gronk and beckham and....other members i'd beat you!!!

 

you know sh1t. stick to the knitting threads.

[posty 2,652]

#WhiteNFLPlayersMatter

[peenie 1,906]

 

you know sh1t. stick to the knitting threads.

 

Well, how about we test this theory?!

Let's play. I can get a league where it's just us and whoever else we know wants to join and see if you can win with your all black team vs my mixed team.

We can even bet $$$ on it. (Like $20 cause I'm not rich like that.)

[edjr 6,579]

 

Well, how about we test this theory?!

Let's play. I can get a league where it's just us and whoever else we know wants to join and see if you can win with your all black team vs my mixed team.

We can even bet $$$ on it. (Like $20 cause I'm not rich like that.)

 

 

You said

 

Nor could you win with an all black team.

 

 

I proved you wrong by naming a team of all black dudes that could win a championship.

 

Is it ideal? No. Is it possible? Yes

 

is it possible to win with an all white team, which the OP asks? No

[peenie 1,906]

I'm saying you need both.

You cannot win with just black or white players.

I'm willing to bet on it.

My biracial team against team white or black.

[Hardcore troubadour 15,134]

I ve done quite well not drafting any Cleveland Browns the last 20 years. I'm way on the plus side. The one time I did was that stiff Braylon Edwards. Thankfully I traded him fast.

[edjr 6,579]

I ve done quite well not drafting any Cleveland Browns the last 20 years. I'm way on the plus side. The one time I did was that stiff Braylon Edwards. Thankfully I traded him fast.

 

 

a great way to do well is do avoid drafting guys on sh1t teams. sometimes there is a josh gordon, but I'll take my chances.

[ROCKFORD 134]

there are open spots in the curly league. pm wilecoyote.

[Mookz 1,341]

there are open spots in the curly league. pm wilecoyote.

 

The curly league still exists? I gave up on it because the last year I was in it there were like three teams.

[WhiteWonder 2,707]

i guess someone already answered with a roster but I think you could.

 

you would have to draft gronk early and make sure you ended up with Jordy Nelson, Julian Edelman and Eric Decker at WR. You would be completely screwed if you missed Woodhead but he is a nice little fantasy RB in ppr formats. Unfortunately there are currently no Hillis types worth a damn as Gerhart struck out in Jax. Zach Zenner might hold some slight promise in Detroit. Kuhn would get you the occasional goal line score.

 

QB could obviously be almost anyone and you could go ahead and do what I never do and use a pick before round 8 on one since your other option are so limited.

 

Aside from Gronk youve got Eifert, Kelce, Olsen...... Rudolph

 

The only way you could really win a title is if you played in a league with only 1 mandatory RB (woodhead) and an extra flex and play two TE's Gronk/Olsen combo with the three WR's listed and Cole Beasley for depth. Amendola, wherever he ends up, Chris Hogan might be a sleeper.

 

Think about it. If you only HAVE to start 1 RB and all of your players stay healthy your QB would be as good as anyones, Your WR trio might be one of the better trios as a healthy Jordy and Julian are both top 15 and Decker flourishes when he is the #2 on his team. Woodhead would score just enough each week to keep you alive and a TE/Flex of Gronk and Olsen would be as good as anyone elses TE/Flex combo....

[kilroy69 1,233]

I'm saying you need both.

You cannot win with just black or white players.

I'm willing to bet on it.

My biracial team against team white or black.

I disagree. I think it would be pretty easy to field a team of all black players that would win.

 

This team would destroy any mixed or white team

 

R. Wilson.

L. bell

A.P.

Aj. green

A.brown

Dez

M. Bennett

[tanatastic 2,062]

I disagree. I think it would be pretty easy to field a team of all black players that would win.

 

You are making a point that doesnt need to be argued.

[kilroy69 1,233]

You are making a point that doesnt need to be argued.

it apparently does as peenie thinks a mixed race team could beat the team I listed.

[tanatastic 2,062]

it apparently does as peenie thinks a mixed race team could beat the team I listed.

That's not a case for needing an argument. It's like if she said water was dry. You wouldn't need to prove it was wet. Of course a black team can win.

[kilroy69 1,233]

That's not a case for needing an argument. It's like if she said water was dry. You wouldn't need to prove it was wet. Of course a black team can win.

if she said something like that she would delete the topic

[southcarolina 166]

 

You would be completely screwed if you missed Woodhead but he is a nice little fantasy RB in ppr formats. Unfortunately there are currently no Hillis types worth a damn as Gerhart struck out in Jax. Zach Zenner might hold some slight promise in Detroit. Kuhn would get you the occasional goal line score.

 

Its splitting hairs, but in a PPR league Raven FB Kyle Juszczyk would be a better choice than Kuhn. in 2015 he had 41 receptions for 320 yard and 4 TD for about 6 PPG.

[dain11279 967]

If you were in a 24 team league and they gave you every best white player in the league you still wouldn't have a shot. Injuries would happen and you'd have absolutely no depth.

[southcarolina 166]

Can we sneak Chris Ivory, Kevin White and James White onto the roster on a technicality?

[peenie 1,906]

Put your money where your mouth is.

Lets get a league and prove it.

My mixed team beats your all white or all black team.

That includes defense being all white or black.

I'll bet $50.

[kilroy69 1,233]

I'll do it. I get the team I have listed vs any mixed team not including those players.