2011 Consensus Rankings Voting Thread: QUARTERBACKS

[Mike FF Today 608]

The Geek Consensus Rankings are back for 2011. worm has graciously offered his services to gather up the results.

 

• Please use this thread to vote for your Top 20 QBs for the 2011 season.
  
• Redraft League, Standard Performance / FF Today scoring should be used to rank the players - NO PPR!
  
• Voting will last until midnight PM PST on Tuesday, 8/23
  
• Once the voting is over, the results will be documented then tabulated.
  
• Traditional polling measures will be used to determine the results
  

Thanks in advance for your participation! We hope this proves to be a helpful resource in establishing a baseline for your upcoming drafts.

 

To make this easy on worm, please format your lists like this...

 

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Michael Vick, PHI

3. Drew Brees, NO

4. Tom Brady, NE

5. Philip Rivers, SD

6. Tony Romo, DAL

7. Peyton Manning, IND

8. Matt Schaub, HOU

9. Eli Manning, NYG

10. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

11. Josh Freeman, TB

12. Jay Cutler, CHI

13. Matt Ryan, ATL

14. Joe Flacco, BAL

15. Matthew Stafford, DET

16. Sam Bradford, STL

17. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

18. Matt Cassel, KC

19. Kyle Orton DEN

20. Kevin Kolb, ARI

Edited August 24, 2011 by Mike FF Today
Update

[PackYourNut 47]

Rodgers

Rivers

Brees

Brady

Romo

Vick

P. Manning

BigBen

Ryan

Stafford

Schaub

E. Manning

Cutler

Freeman

Bradford

Cassel

Flacco

Fitzpatrick

Orton

Kolb

[Jarvis Basnight 119]

Vick

Rodgers

Rivers

Brady

Romo

Brees

P. Manning

BigBen

Ryan

Schaub

Stafford

E. Manning

Kolb

Orton

Flacco

Cutler

Freeman

Bradford

Cassel

Fitzpatrick

[DexterMorgan 5]

Rodgers

Vick

Brady

Rivers

Manning

Brees

Romo

Rothlisberger

Schaub

Ryan

Stafford

E. Manning

Kolb

Orton

Freeman

Bradfird

Flacco

Cutler

Bradford

Cassel

Fitzpatrick

[Echo52 0]

Here's how I think the top 20 will shape up this season:

 

1. Aaron Rodgers - GB
   
2. Tom Brady - NE
   
3. Philip Rivers - SD
   
4. Drew Brees - NO
   
5. Tony Romo - DAL
   
6. Michael Vick - PHI
   
7. Peyton Manning - IND
   
8. Matt Ryan - ATL
   
9. Matt Schaub - HOU
   
10. Eli Manning - NYG
    
11. Ben Roethlisberger - PIT
    
12. Matthew Stafford - DET
    
13. Jay Cutler - CHI
    
14. Joe Flacco - BAL
    
15. Sam Bradford - STL
    
16. Josh Freeman - TB
    
17. Kevin Kolb - ARI
    
18. Matt Cassel - KC
    
19. Mark Sanchez - NYJ
    
20. Colt McCoy - CLE
    

 

Yes, I know Vick is low - but I'm not high on him. Injury concerns, teams have tape on him after a full year now, etc. I'd put Peyton above him as well had Peyton not have the neck problems(which I think will cause him to get off to a slow start, but then be fine).

 

All in all, definitely a TON of value at Quarterback this year.

[Houston Texans 10]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Drew Brees, NO

3. Tom Brady, NE

4. Michael Vick, PHI

5. Peyton Manning, IND

6. Philip Rivers, SD

7. Tony Romo, DAL

8. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

9. Eli Manning, NYG

10. Matt Ryan, ATL

11. Jay Cutler, CHI

12. Matt Schaub, HOU

13. Josh Freeman, TB

14. David Garrard, JAX

15. Donovan McNabb, MIN

16. Joe Flacco, BAL

17. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

18. Sam Bradford, STL

19. Cam Newton, CAR

20. Matthew Stafford, DET

[Bishop82 61]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Tom Brady, NE

3. Drew Brees, NO

4. Philip Rivers, SD

5. Michael Vick, PHI

6. Peyton Manning, IND

7. Tony Romo, DAL

8. Matt Schaub, HOU

9. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

10. Eli Manning, NYG

11. Jay Cutler, CHI

12. Joe Flacco, BAL

13. Matt Ryan, ATL

14. Josh Freeman, TB

15. Matthew Stafford, DET

16. Sam Bradford, STL

17. Kevin Kolb, ARI

18. Matt Cassel, KC

19. Kyle Orton DEN

20. Colt McCoy, CLE

[Swim54 4]

1. Vick

2. Aaron Rodgers

3. Tom Brady

4. Drew Brees

5. Phillip Rivers

6. Peyton Manning

7. Tony Romo

8. Ben Roethlisberger

9. Matt Schaub

10. Eli Manning

11. Matt Ryan

12. Matthew Stafford

13. Sam Bradford

14. Josh Freemen

15. Joe Flacco

16. Jay Culter

17. Kyle Orton

18. Ryan Fitzpatrick

19. Mark Sanchez

20. Kevin Kolb

[Nujet2002 0]

1. Michael Vick, PHI

2. Tom Brady, NE

3. Phillip Rivers, SD

4. Aaron Rodgers, GB

5. Tony Romo, DAL

6. Drew Brees, NO

7. Peyton Manning, IND

8. Matt Schaub, HOU

9. Matt Ryan, ATL

10. Kevin Kolb, PHI

11. Matt Stafford, DET

12. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

13. Joe Flacco, BAL

14. Sam Bradford, STL

15. Eli Manning, NYG

16. Jay Cutler, CHI

17. Josh Freeman, TB

18. Kyle Orton, DEN

19. Mark Sanchez, NYJ

20. Alex Smith, SF

[OakHeadFootball 1]

1. Phillip Rivers

2. Aaron Rodgers

3. Tom Brady

4. Drew Brees

5. Peyton Manning

6. Vick

7. Ben Roethlisberger

8. Tony Romo

9. Eli Manning

10. Matt Schaub

11. Matt Ryan

12. Joe Flacco

13. Jay Culter

14. Kyle Orton

15. Matt Cassel

16. Mark Sanchez

17. Matthew Stafford

18. Sam Bradford

19. Kevin Kolb

20. Ryan Fitzpatrick

[Bigtraine 24]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Philip Rivers, SD

3. Drew Brees, NO

4. Michael Vick, PHI

5. Tom Brady, NE

6. Matt Schaub, HOU

7. Peyton Manning, IND

8. Tony Romo, DAL

9. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

10. Matthew Stafford, DET

11. Eli Manning, NYG

12. Matt Ryan, ATL

13. Josh Freeman, TB

14. Joe Flacco, BAL

15. Sam Bradford, STL

16. Kevin Kolb, ARI

17. Jay Cutler, CHI

18. Kyle Orton, DEN

19. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

20. Mark Sanchez, NYJ

[Phurfur 70]

1 Rodgers, Aaron QB GB

2 Rivers, Philip QB SD

3 Brees, Drew QB NO

4 Brady, Tom QB NE

5 Vick, Michael QB PHI

6 Manning, Peyton QB IND

7 Romo, Tony QB DAL

8 Roethlisberger, Ben QB PIT

9 Freeman, Josh QB TB

10 Manning, Eli QB NYG

11 Ryan, Matt QB ATL

12 Flacco, Joe QB BAL

13 Schaub, Matt QB HOU

14 Cutler, Jay QB CHI

15 Bradford, Sam QB STL

16 Fitzpatrick, Ryan QB BUF

17 Cassel, Matt QB KC

18 Garrard, David QB JAC

19 Sanchez, Mark QB NYJ

20 Kolb, Kevin

[NorthernVike 2,080]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Drew Brees, NO

3. Tom Brady, NE

4. Philip Rivers, SD

5. Peyton Manning, IND

6. Tony Romo, DAL

7. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

8. Matt Ryan, ATL

9. Matt Schaub, HOU

10. Mike Vick, PHI

11. Jay Cutler, CHI

12. Eli Manning, NYG

13. Josh Freeman, TB

14. David Garrard, JAX

15. Joe Flacco, BAL

16. Donovan McNabb, MIN

17. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

18. Sam Bradford, STL

19. Kevin Klob, AZ

20. Mark Sanchez, NYJ

[polecatt 403]

1. Mike Vick

2. Tom Brady

3. Aaron Rodgers

4. Peyton Manning

5. Phillip Rivers

6. Drew Brees

7. Tony Romo

8. Ben Roethlisberger

9. Eli Manning

10. Matt Schaub

11. Matt Ryan

12. Josh Freeman

13. Matthew Stafford

14. Joe Flacco

15. Jay Cutler

16. Matt Cassel

17. Sam Bradford

18. Kevin Kolb

19. Kyle Orton

20. Ryan Fitzpatrick

[worm 34]

1. Michael Vick

2. Aaron Rodgers

3. Drew Brees

4. Peyton Manning

5. Philip Rivers

6. Tom Brady

7. Tony Romo

8. Matt Schaub

9. Eli Manning

10. Ben Roethlisberger

11. Josh Freeman

12. Jay Cutler

13. Joe Flacco

14. Matt Stafford

15. Ryan Fitzpatrick

16. Sam Bradford

17. Matt Ryan

18. Matt Cassel

19. Mark Sanchez

20. Kevin Kolb

[BunnysBastatrds 1,920]

Brees

Rodgers

Brady

Rivers

P manning

Big Ben

Romo

Schaub

Ryan

Stafford

E Manning

Vick

Cutler

Freeman

Flaco

Bradford

Cassel

Kolb

Orton

Sanchez

[ampheels 3]

1) Aaron Rodgers

2) Michael Vick

3) Drew Brees

4) Tom Brady

5) Phil Rivers

6) Peyton Manning

7) Tony Romo

8) Big Ben

9) Eli Manning

10) Matt Stafford

11) Matt Ryan

12) Matt Schuab

13) Sam Bradford

14) Jay Cutler

15) Kevin Kolb

16) Josh Freeman

17) Joe Flacco

18) Matt Cassel

19) Kyle Orton

20) Colt McCoy

[Lay the Mallett Down 0]

1.Tom Brady

2.Aaron Rogers

3.Phillip Rivers

4.Drew Brees

5.Mike Vick

6.Peyton Manning

7.Big Ben

8.Tony Romo

9.Josh Freeman

10.Matt Schuab

11.Eli Manning

12.Matt Stafford

13.Matt Ryan

14.Sam Bradford

15.Jay Coutler

16.Joe Flacco

17.Matt Cassel

18.Kevin Kolb

19.Kyle Orton

20.Matt Hassselbeck

[ralphster 274]

1. Rodgers - GB

2. Rivers - SD

3. Romo - DAL

4. Brees - NO

5. Brady - NE

6. Manning - IND

7. Rothlisberger - PIT

8. Vick - PHI

9. Schaub - HOU

10. Ryan - ATL

11. Manning - NYG

12. Freeman - TB

13. Stafford - DET

14. Bradford - STL

15. Flacco - BAL

16. Kolb - ARZ

17. Cutler - CHI

18. Sanchez - NYJ

19. Cassel - KC

20. Hasselbeck - TEN

[DC 9]

1 Aaron Rodgers, GB

2 Michael Vick, PHI

3 Tom Brady, NE

4 Peyton Manning, IND

5 Drew Brees, NO

6 Phillip Rivers, SD

7 Tony Romo, DAL

8 Matt Ryan, ATL

9 Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

10 Josh Freeman, TB

11 Matt Schaub, HOU

12 Eli Manning, NYG

13 Jay Cutler, CHI

14 Matt Stafford, DET

15 Sam Bradford, STL

16 Donovan McNabb, MIN

17 Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

18 Joe Flacco, BAL

19 Mark Sanchez, NYJ

20 Matt Cassel, KC

[ST_Pete 3]

1 AARON RODGERS, QB, GB

2 MICHAEL VICK, QB, PHI

3 PEYTON MANNING, QB, IND

4 TOM BRADY, QB, NE

5 DREW BREES, QB, NO

6 PHILLIP RIVERS, QB, SD

7 TONY ROMO, QB, DAL

8 MATT SCHAUB, QB HOU

9 JOSH FREEMAN, QB, TB

10 ELI MANNING, QB, NYG

11 JOE FLACCO, QB, BAL

12 MATT STAFFORD, QB, DET

13 BEN ROETHLISBERGER, QB, PIT

14 RYAN FITZPATRICK, QB, BUFF

15 KYLE ORTON, QB, DEN

16 KEVIN KOLB, QB, PHI

17 MATT CASSEL, QB, KC

18 MATT RYAN, QB, ATL

19 JAY CUTLER, QB, CHI

20 SAM BRADFORD, QB, STL

[tecklc2112 7]

1. Matt Ryan ATL

2. Philip Rivers SD

3. Tony Romo DAL

4. Aaron Rodgers GB

5. Tom Brady NE

6. Peyton Manning IND

7. Matt Schaub HOU

8. Drew Brees NO

9. Eli Manning NYG

10. Ben Roethlisberger PIT

11. Mike Vick PHI

12. Matthew Stafford DET

13. Sam Bradford STL

14. Josh Freeman TB

15. Jay Cutler CHI

16. Matt Cassel KC

17. Joe Flacco BAL

18. Kevin Kolb AZ

19. Kyle Orton DEN

20. Colt McCoy CLE

[Gridiron Mafia 1]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Drew Brees, NO

3. Mike Vick, PHI

4. Philip Rivers, SD

5. Peyton Manning, IND

6. Tom Brady, NE

7. Eli Manning, NYG

8. Matt Schaub, HOU

9. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

10. Tony Romo, DAL

11. Matt Ryan, ATL

12. Matthew Stafford, DET

13. Joe Flacco, BAL

14. Josh Freeman, TB

15. Jay Cutler, CHI

16. Kevin Kolb, ARI

17. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

18. Donovan McNabb, MIN

19. Kyle Orton DEN

20. Matt Cassel, KC

[Melissa Stark 1]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2.Tom Brady, NE

3. Drew Brees, NO

4. Philip Rivers, SD

5. Peyton Manning, IND

6. Michael Vick, PHI

7. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

8. Josh Freeman, TB

9. Eli Manning, NYG

10. Tony Romo, DAL

11. Matt Schaub, HOU

12. Matt Ryan, ATL

13. Joe Flacco, BAL

14. Jay Cutler, CHI

15. Matt Cassel, KC

16. Sam Bradford, STL

17. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

18. Matthew Stafford, DET

19. Kyle Orton DEN

20. McNabb, Minn.

[WhiteWonder 2,172]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Phillip Rivers, SD

3. Tom Brady, NE

4. Drew Brees, NO

5. Mike Vick, PHI

6. Peyton Manning, IND

7. Tony Romo, DAL

8. Matt Schaub, HOU

9. Eli Manning, NYG

10. Big Ben, PIT

11. Matt Ryan, ATL

12. Josh Freeman, TB

13. Matt Stafford, DET

14. Jay Cutler, CHI

15. Kevin Kolb, ARI

16. Sam Bradford, STL

17. Mark Sanchez, NYJ

18. Kyle Orton, DEN

19. Joe Flacco, BAL

20. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

[Raider 84 29]

1. Rodgers

2. Rivers

3. Brady

4. Brees

5. Vick

6. P Manning

7. Romo

8. Schaub

9. Stafford

10. E. Manning

11. Big Ben

12. Ryan

13. Freeman

14. Cassel

15. Flacco

16. Cutler

17. Fitzpatrick

18. Kolb

19. Orton

20. McNabb

[carmo911 2]

Aaron Rodgers, GB

Drew Brees, NO

Phillip Rivers, SD

Michael Vick, PHI

Tony Romo, DAL

Peyton Manning, IND

Tom Brady, NE

Matt Schaub, HOU

Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

Josh Freeman, TB

Eli Manning, NYG

Jay Cutler, CHI

Kyle Orton, DEN

Matt Ryan, ATL

Joe Flacco, BAL

Kevin Kolb, ARI

Matt Cassel, KC

Matt Hasselbeck, TEN

Sam Bradford, STL

Matt Stafford, DET

[JKAP21 0]

1. Michael Vick

2. Aaron Rogers

3. Tom Brady

4. Phillip Rivers

5. Drew Brees

6. Peyton Manning

7. Tony Romo

8. Matt Schaub

9. Josh Freeman

10. Eli Manning

11. Ben Roethlisberger

12. Matt Stafford

13. Matt Ryan

14. Ryan Fitzpatrick

15. Sam Bradford

16. Matt Cassel

17. Joe Flacco

18. Jay Cutler

19. Kevin Kolb

20. Kyle Orton

[rocco91 0]

1. Michael Vick, PHI

2. Tom Brady

3. Aaron Rodgers, GB

4. Drew Brees, NO

5. Peyton Manning, IND

6. Philip Rivers, SD

7. Tony Romo, DAL

8. Matt Schaub, HOU

9. Eli Manning, NYG

10. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

11. Matt Ryan, ATL

12. Josh Freeman, TB

13. Matthew Stafford, DET

14. Jay Cutler, CHI

15. Joe Flacco, BAL

16. Sam Bradford, STL

17. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

18. Matt Cassel, KC

19. Kyle Orton DEN

20. Kevin Kolb, ARI

[Boilermaker04 11]

1 Aaron Rodgers GB

2 Tom Brady NE

3 Philip Rivers SD

4 Michael Vick PHI

5 Ben Roethlisberger PIT

6 Tony Romo DAL

7 Drew Brees NO

8 Matthew Stafford DET

9 Matt Schaub HOU

10 Peyton Manning IND

11 Josh Freeman TB

12 Eli Manning NYG

13 Matt Ryan ATL

14 Jay Cutler CHI

15 Sam Bradford STL

16 Ryan Fitzpatrick BUF

17 Kyle Orton DEN

18 Donovan McNabb MIN

19 Matt Cassel KC

20 Cam Newton CAR

[TD Ryan2 314]

1 Tom Brady NE

2 Michael Vick PHI

3 Aaron Rodgers GB

------------------------

4 Drew Brees NO

5 Philip Rivers SD

6 Peyton Manning IND

------------------------

7 Tony Romo DAL

8 Matt Ryan ATL

9 Ben Roethlisberger PIT

-------------------------

10 Matt Schaub HOU

11 Eli Manning NYG

-------------------------

12 Sam Bradford STL

13 Matthew Stafford DET

-------------------------

14 Donovan McNabb MIN

15 Josh Freeman TB

16 Joe Flacco BAL

17 Kevin Kolb ARI

18 Ryan Fitzpatrick BUF

19 Matt Cassel KC

20 Kyle Orton DEN

--------------------------

[Pariah 0]

1. Michael Vick, PHI

2. Aaron Rodgers, GB

3. Drew Brees, NO

4. Tom Brady, NE

5. Philip Rivers, SD

6. Peyton Manning, IND

7. Tony Romo, DAL

8. Matt Schaub, HOU

9. Eli Manning, NYG

10. Josh Freeman, TB

11. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

12. Kyle Orton DEN

13. Jay Cutler, CHI

14. Joe Flacco, BAL

15. Matt Ryan, ATL

16. Matthew Stafford, DET

17. Sam Bradford, STL

18. Kevin Kolb, ARI

19. Matt Cassel, KC

20. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

[Herbivore 905]

1. Tom Brady

2. Philip Rivers

3. Aaron Rodgers

4. Drew Brees

5. Peyton Manning

6. Tony Romo

7. Ben Roethlisberger

8. Eli Manning

9. Matt Ryan

10. Matt Schaub

11. Mike Vick

12. Joe Flacco

13. Jay Culter

14. Kyle Orton

15. Matt Cassel

16. Mark Sanchez

17. Matthew Stafford

18. Sam Bradford

19. Josh Freeman

20. Ryan Fitzpatrick

[cmac13 0]

1 Rodgers, Aaron QB GB

2 Stafford, Matthew QB DET

3 Brees, Drew QB NO

4 Rivers, Philip QB SD

5 Manning, Peyton QB IND

6 Brady, Tom QB NE

7 Bradford, Sam QB STL

8 Ryan, Matt QB ATL

9 Vick, Michael QB PHI

10 Freeman, Josh QB TB

11 Romo, Tony QB DAL

12 Roethlisberger, Ben QB PIT

13 Manning, Eli QB NYG

14 Schaub, Matt QB HOU

15 Flacco, Joe QB BAL

16 Cutler, Jay QB CHI

17 Sanchez, Mark QB NYJ

18 Cassel, Matt QB KC

19 Fitzpatrick, Ryan QB BUF

20 Kolb, Kevin QB ARI

[Brad GLuckman 518]

1. Tom Brady, NE

2. Phillip Rivers, SD

3. Aaron Rodgers, GB

4. Drew Brees, NO

5. Michael Vick, PHI

6. Peyton Manning, IND

7. Matt Schaub, HOU

8. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

9. Jay Cutler, CHI

10. Matt Ryan, ATL

11. Tony Romo, DAL

12. Matt Stafford, DET

13. Kyle Orton, DEN

14. Joe Flacco, BAL

15. Eli Manning, NYG

16. Kevin Kolb, ARI

17. Sam Bradford, STL

18. Josh Freeman, TB

19. Matt Cassel, KC

20. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

[Perennial Contender 18]

1. Philip Rivers, SD

2. Aaron Rodgers, GB

3. Tom Brady, NE

4. Drew Brees, NO

5. Michael Vick, PHI

6. Peyton Manning, IND

7. Tony Romo, DAL

8. Matt Ryan, ATL

9. Matt Schaub, HOU

10. Josh Freeman, TB

11. Matthew Stafford, DET

12. Kevin Kolb, ARI

13. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

14. Eli Manning, NYG

15. Jay Cutler, CHI

16. Sam Bradford, STL

17. Colt McCoy, CLE

18. Matt Cassel, KC

19. Kyle Orton DEN

20. Joe Flacco, BAL

[We Tigers 71]

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB

2. Michael Vick, PHI

3. Philip Rivers, SD

4. Tom Brady, NE

5. Drew Brees, NO

6. Tony Romo, DAL

7. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT

8. Peyton Manning, IND

9. Matt Schaub, HOU

10. Josh Freeman, TB

11. Matt Ryan, ATL

12. Eli Manning, NYG

13. Matthew Stafford, DET

14. Kevin Kolb, ARI

15. Joe Flacco, BAL

16. Kyle Orton, DEN

17. Sam Bradford, STL

18. Jay Cutler, CHI

19. Ryan Fitzpatrick, BUF

20. Donovan McNabb, MIN

[stosher1 0]

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Phillip Rivers

3. Michael Vick

4. Drew Brees

5. Tom Brady

6. Tony Romo

7. Peyton Manning

8. Ben Roethlisberger

9. Eli Manning

10. Matt Ryan

11. Matt Shaub

12. Matthem Stafford

13. Kyle Orton

14. Kevin Kolb

15. Jay Cutler

16. Josh Freeman

17. Sam Bradford

18. Donovan McNabb

19. Joe Flacco

20. Jason Campbell

[worm 34]

Voting is closed.